Follow the order of a story

Distinguish chronology from presentation; explain withholding, return, contrast and consequential events.

What to practice

  • Distinguish chronology from presentation; explain withholding, return, contrast and consequential events.

Every story has two orders. One is the order in which events happened: the chronology. The other is the order in which the reader learns about them: the telling order, sometimes called the order of presentation. When the two match, a story moves forward like a clock. When they differ, the writer has made a choice about what you learn first, what you learn late and what you must work out for yourself. Structure questions on the AP exam ask you to explain those choices. They are not asking what happened. They are asking why the telling is arranged as it is, and what the arrangement makes you notice, expect or feel.

This chapter shows you how to separate the two orders, recognize the common structural moves and explain each move's effect in terms specific to the passage. Its practice uses "The Gift of the Magi," a story whose narrator repeatedly stops, digresses and delays.

Separate story order from telling order

To analyze structure, first rebuild the chronology. Number the events in the order they happened. Then number them in the order the passage presents them. The places where the two numberings differ are the places to examine.

Worked example: two timelines

The passage below is an original practice passage written for this guide.

The window was already boarded when Marcus came home. His father was sweeping glass from the porch and did not look up. Marcus thought of the baseball in his hand that afternoon, the swing, the sound, the way he had run before he heard anything break.

StepChronology (what happened)Telling order (what the reader learns)
1Marcus swings at the ball.The window has been boarded.
2Marcus runs.The father sweeps glass and does not look up.
3The window breaks, unheard by Marcus.Marcus remembers the swing and the sound.
4The father boards the window.Marcus remembers running "before he heard anything break."
5Marcus comes home and sees the board.

The passage opens with the aftermath, so the reader stands beside Marcus at the moment he must face a consequence. The cause arrives later, as memory, which makes it feel like a confession he has not yet spoken aloud. The final clause adds a fact that chronology alone would not stress: he fled before he knew what he had done. The arrangement shifts attention from the accident to his avoidance and to his father's silence.

  • Weak: The author uses a flashback to give background information.
  • Strong: By opening in the aftermath and delivering the cause as Marcus's memory, the passage makes the reader feel his dread before learning its source, and the final clause turns an accident into an act of avoidance.

Try it. Rewrite the passage in chronological order in two sentences. What disappears?

Check your reasoning. In chronological order ("Marcus hit a ball and ran; later he found the window boarded and his father sweeping"), the scene becomes a report of an accident. The dread of the homecoming disappears, because the reader already knows what the father knows. The silence of "did not look up" also loses its weight, since it no longer delays an explanation.

Know the common structural moves

Learn these moves as questions to ask, not as labels to collect.

Opening placement

Where does the story begin? A story may open with a result, a problem, a sum of money, a single object or the middle of an action. Ask what the reader must carry forward from the first sentences, and what remains unexplained.

Pause and digression

A narrator can stop the clock: describing a room while a character cries, explaining a custom or commenting on life in general. Ask what the pause supplies (context, judgment, humor) and what it postpones.

Delayed exposition and withholding

Exposition is background information. Placing it late, after the reader has seen the action it explains, can make that action seem charged before the reader knows why. Withholding is broader: the narrator, or the story's arrangement, keeps a fact back. Distinguish two kinds of not-knowing. In one, the reader is kept from a fact that a character knows. In the other, a character lacks a fact that the reader has; that gap is dramatic irony.

Flashback and return

A flashback presents an earlier episode within the telling of a later one. The return to the present matters as much as the flashback. Ask how the present moment reads differently once the past has been supplied. Not every mention of the past is a flashback: a brief clause such as "that had been his father's and his grandfather's" is background, not a scene.

Pacing: scene and summary

A scene presents events at roughly the speed at which they happen, often with dialogue. Summary compresses time ("the next two hours passed"). Expansion stretches a brief moment across many sentences. Where a passage slows, it usually signals importance; where it races, it may be moving past a transition or keeping attention elsewhere.

Planting and payoff

A planted detail gains significance later. Claim foreshadowing only when the passage itself, or the question, supplies the later event. A detail that "might" matter in part of a story you have not been given is a guess, not evidence.

Juxtaposition and contrast

Placing two moments side by side invites comparison: a quiet scene after a loud one, a memory of plenty beside present scarcity. Ask what the contrast reveals that neither moment shows alone.

Consequential events

A consequential event changes what is possible afterward. It closes options, forces a choice or reveals information that alters a relationship. When a question asks which event matters most, look for the one after which the situation cannot return to what it was.

Worked example: a pattern and its break

Original practice passage:

Every Thursday Mrs. Lin bought two oranges, one for herself and one that she set on the empty chair across her kitchen table. The grocer, who had known her for eleven years, always chose the brightest pair. This Thursday she bought one. He bagged it without a word, and after she had gone, he set a second orange aside on the counter, as if someone might still come for it.

The passage establishes a habit with "Every Thursday," then breaks it with "This Thursday." The event that matters is never stated. The reader infers from the change in number, and from the "empty chair" mentioned earlier, that a loss of some kind has occurred. The arrangement does three things. It makes the reader discover the loss through a broken pattern, as the grocer does. It moves the emotional response to the grocer, whose gesture is delayed until "after she had gone." And it leaves the loss unnamed, which keeps attention on how two people acknowledge it without speaking.

Notice the limit. The passage does not say whom the second orange was for, or whether that person has died, moved away or simply stopped coming. A careful answer says "a loss," not "her husband's death." The withholding is part of the meaning, and an interpretation that fills the gap with invented facts misreads it.

Try it. In one sentence, explain why the grocer's gesture is placed after Mrs. Lin leaves rather than while she is in the shop.

Check your reasoning. Placing the gesture after she leaves makes it private: the grocer respects her silence in her presence and expresses his recognition only when no one can see it, which shows both tact and quiet grief. If he set the orange aside in front of her, the scene would become a conversation about the loss, and the restraint that defines both characters would disappear.

Worked example: how pace signals weight

Compare two original versions of one moment.

Version 1: She waited an hour for the results.

Version 2: The nurse's shoes squeaked twice in the hallway, stopped outside the door and moved on. She counted the ceiling tiles. Forty-two. She counted them again and got forty-one.

Version 1 compresses the hour into a fact. Version 2 expands a few minutes into sensory detail and repeated action, and the miscount suggests a mind too anxious to hold a number. Questions about pace ask why a passage lingers where it does. In Version 2, the expansion places the reader inside the waiting, so the result, when it comes, will land with more force. A response that says "the author slows down to build suspense" is not wrong, but it is incomplete. Name what the slowing reveals: here, the character's fear and her effort to control it.

Common errors to repair

  1. Retelling the plot. If your answer could be replaced by a summary, you have described events, not their arrangement. Repair: name where something is placed and what that placement does.
  2. Calling every past reference a flashback. A clause of background is not a scene. Repair: reserve "flashback" for an earlier episode presented within a later one.
  3. Claiming foreshadowing of absent events. If the passage stops before the payoff, you cannot assert one. Repair: describe what the detail does within the passage itself.
  4. Using a generic effect. "Builds suspense" and "keeps the reader interested" fit almost any story. Repair: say what the reader is made to wonder, notice or feel, and why that matters here.
  5. Confusing narrator withholding with character ignorance. When the narrator delays a fact, the reader is kept waiting; when a character lacks a fact the reader has, the result is dramatic irony. Repair: ask who knows what, and when.
  6. Ignoring the return. Many students explain a flashback and stop. Repair: explain how the present scene reads differently once the past has been supplied.

Structure questions on the exam

Typical stems include:

  • "The second paragraph primarily serves to …"
  • "The shift from X to Y in paragraph N …"
  • "The placement of the sentence '…' has which effect?"
  • "Which best describes the organization of the passage as a whole?"

Use a three-question routine. What does the reader know immediately before this part, and what does the reader know immediately after it? What does this part make possible or meaningful in the part that follows? Does the answer choice describe the part's function, or merely its content? Wrong answers to structure questions often describe content accurately but misstate function, or they claim a move, such as a flashback or a shift in point of view, that the passage never makes.

Precise verbs help in both multiple-choice reasoning and essays: establishes, interrupts, delays, compresses, expands, juxtaposes, returns to, reveals, reframes, complicates. Each names a different action. "Interrupts" and "delays" both stop the action, but "delays" emphasizes what is postponed, while "interrupts" emphasizes what is broken off.

Writing about structure in an essay

A structural observation becomes a thesis when it explains meaning. One useful check is this pattern: By [arrangement], the author makes the reader [experience or understand something], so that [meaning]. It is not a formula that guarantees credit; use it to confirm that your claim has all three parts.

  • Weak: The passage about Mrs. Lin uses structure to create mystery.
  • Better: The passage withholds the reason Mrs. Lin buys only one orange.
  • Strong: By establishing a weekly habit and then breaking it without explanation, the passage makes readers discover a loss the way the grocer does, so that his silent gesture becomes the only acknowledgment the loss receives.

Practice

Your chapter practice uses O. Henry's "The Gift of the Magi," first published in a New York newspaper in December 1905 and collected in The Four Million in 1906. Many readers already know how this story ends. The multiple-choice questions use only the story's first seventeen paragraphs and do not require the ending, so answer every question from the printed passage alone.

  1. Before reading the questions, make a two-column chart for paragraphs 1 through 8. In one column list events in chronological order; in the other list them in the order the narrator presents them. Mark every place where the narrator stops the action.
  2. Answer the twelve multiple-choice questions, Questions 67–78. Allow about eighteen minutes.
  3. Write the prose-analysis essay, Written task 4, which supplies the story's conclusion as a separate passage printed with the prompt. Plan for about ten minutes and write for about thirty. The two response pages are practice space, not a length limit.
  4. Check your answers in "Answers, explanations and written responses," under Chapter 7. For each error, decide which of the six common errors above it most resembles, then reread the section named in its repair reference.

Review and retrieval

In three days. From memory, define chronology and telling order, and list four structural moves with a one-line question for each. Then reread the Marcus passage and explain its order without looking at the table.

In one week. Take a paragraph from your practice essay and replace every generic effect ("builds suspense," "engages the reader") with a statement of what the reader is made to notice or wonder.

In three weeks. In a new short-fiction passage, rebuild the chronology before reading the questions, and mark a pause, a delay and a return if they occur. Chapter 8 builds on this work by asking how much a narrator knows and how far a reader should trust that narrator's account.

Use this chapter companion

Review the lesson, attempt the original practice, then check the explanation. Your printed study guide remains complete without the website.

Independence

Skill by Skill Prep is independent. SAT® and AP® are trademarks registered by the College Board, which is not affiliated with, and does not endorse, this website or book. PSAT/NMSQT® is a registered trademark of the College Board and the National Merit Scholarship Corporation, which are not affiliated with, and do not endorse, this site. Bluebook™ is a trademark of the College Board. ACT® is a trademark of ACT Education Corp., which is not affiliated with and does not endorse this website or book. Desmos is a trademark of Desmos Studio PBC. Practice results describe these questions, not official scores or admission predictions.

Last updated .