Locate the speaker of a poem

Establish the speaking situation, implied audience, stance, tone and change without assuming autobiography.

What to practice

  • Establish the speaking situation, implied audience, stance, tone and change without assuming autobiography.

A short story usually tells you who is present, where they are and what is happening. A poem often begins in the middle of a voice and leaves you to reconstruct the rest. Before you can analyze imagery, form or argument, you need a working answer to a simpler question: who is speaking, to whom, in what situation, and how does that speaker's attitude change? This chapter builds that answer from evidence on the page. It also guards against a persistent error in poetry analysis: assuming that the "I" of a poem is the poet.

The speaker is a made voice

The speaker is the voice that delivers the poem. Like a narrator in fiction, the speaker is constructed by the poet. Sometimes the speaker is plainly someone else: a historical figure, an animal, a soldier or a person long dead. Sometimes the speaker sounds personal, uses "I" and describes feelings the poet may well have had. Even then, treat the voice as a speaker. You can analyze what the poem gives you; you cannot verify what the poet felt.

Original practice poem written for this guide:

They pay me in oil and in silence. I keep
the lamp at Cutter's Point and log the ships
that pass without a word to me, as ships
should pass, if I have done my work.

The speaker is a lighthouse keeper, and no reader would assume that the poet tends a lamp. But the habit this example builds matters most when a poem seems autobiographical. An answer choice that says "the poet recalls his own childhood" is almost always weaker than one that says "the speaker recalls a childhood," because only the second is something the text can establish.

Try it. What does the keeper value about the ships passing "without a word"? Answer in one sentence that uses the poem's last line.

Check your reasoning. Silence is the sign of success: ships "should pass" quietly "if I have done my work," so the keeper finds pride in an invisible job. A response that calls the keeper simply lonely ignores the professional satisfaction in "as ships / should pass."

Build the speaking situation

Reconstruct the situation with five questions. Write brief answers in the margin and mark the words that support each one.

  1. Who speaks? Look at pronouns, self-descriptions and what the speaker notices.
  2. To whom? Look for "you," names, commands, questions and terms of address. If there is no addressee, the poem may be a reflection overheard by the reader.
  3. Where and when? Look at place details, tense and time words.
  4. What is the occasion? What prompts the speech: a loss, a question, a sight, a memory?
  5. What does the speaker want? To persuade, to remember, to justify, to praise, to resist?

Some answers will be uncertain. Record uncertainty honestly ("a relative or partner; the poem does not say") rather than filling the gap with a guess.

Worked example: reconstructing a situation

Original practice poem written for this guide:

     Inventory

     I counted the jars on the cellar shelf:
     peaches, then beans, then the dark plum jam
     she labeled in pencil the August she left.
     I wiped every lid. I set them back in rows.
 5   It is good to be useful. It is good
     to know where everything is.
     You ask why I haven't opened one.
     Hold it up to the window. See how the peaches
     still keep the light, as if it were that summer,
10   the kitchen loud with steam and her talking.

Who speaks? An unnamed "I" who has kept the jars of a woman who "left." The relationship is unstated. A child, partner or sibling would all fit, so do not choose one.

To whom? For six lines, no one seems to be addressed. Line 7 reveals a listener: "You ask why I haven't opened one." The poem is the speaker's answer to a question, which recasts the earlier lines as a reply rather than a private list.

Where and when? A cellar, in the present, some time after an August when "she left." Whether she moved away or died is left open, and the poem's restraint depends on that openness.

Occasion and motive. The listener's question prompts the speech. The speaker wants to explain without quite explaining. Instead of saying "I can't bear to," the speaker asks the listener to look at the light in the jar.

Audience changes what a speaker says

A poem's audience can be an addressed listener, an implied listener or the reader alone.

  • Addressed listener: the speaker names or speaks to someone ("You ask . . . ," "My love, . . ."). The speech is shaped by that relationship.
  • Apostrophe: the speaker addresses someone absent or something that cannot answer, such as a dead friend, a season or an object.
  • No addressee: the speaker reflects, describes or remembers, and the reader overhears.

Ask how the speech would differ for a different listener. In "Inventory," the listener's question is probably practical: why keep food you never eat? The speaker's answer moves from practical language ("useful," "where everything is") to sensory memory, as if facts could not answer the question. A late-revealed audience often makes you reread the poem. Words that seemed private were partly a defense offered to someone else.

When a speaker reveals more than intended

Some poems, often called dramatic monologues, give one speaker an occasion and a listener and let the speech expose qualities the speaker does not recognize. The reader stands where a careful listener would, hearing the speaker's claims and noticing what they leave out. This connects directly to Chapter 8's narrators, and the same caution applies: unintended self-revelation must be shown by the words. Look for a boast that sounds like a threat, praise that keeps returning to the speaker's own importance or an excuse offered before anyone has accused.

Return to the lighthouse keeper. "If I have done my work" is modest, but it also defines the keeper's worth entirely by what others never notice. A reader could argue that the keeper's pride depends on being invisible, a claim the keeper never makes but the phrasing supports. Present such a reading as an inference with its evidence, and keep it in proportion: four lines do not prove that the keeper is bitter or deluded.

Stance and tone

Stance is the speaker's position toward a subject: approving, resisting, uncertain or divided. Tone is the attitude conveyed by the speaker's language. Tone is not a mood you feel while reading. It is an inference from diction, images, syntax and sound, so you must be able to point to the words that create it.

Use precise tone words, and be ready to justify the distinction:

Too vagueMore exact optionsWhat distinguishes them
happyserene, exuberant, gratefulCalm acceptance versus energetic delight versus thanks directed at a source
sadwistful, mournful, desolateGentle longing versus open grief versus emptiness
angryindignant, bitter, exasperatedMoral protest versus lingering resentment versus worn-out impatience
respectfulreverent, deferential, admiringSacred awe versus yielding to authority versus appreciation
funnywry, playful, mockingDry self-aware humor versus lighthearted fun versus ridicule

Original practice poem written for this guide:

Old coat, you kept the shape of my shoulders
longer than I kept the job you were bought for.
Now you hang by the door like a patient question
I answer every morning by walking past.

The speaker addresses a coat (apostrophe) and admits a lost job. The tone is wry, not bitter: the speaker jokes at their own expense ("longer than I kept the job"), and "patient question" lends the coat a gentle persistence rather than an accusation. The last line adds a mild ache, since walking past is an answer that avoids answering. A precise description would be "wry, with an undertone of rueful avoidance." Mixed tones are common; describe the mixture rather than forcing one word.

Try it. Choose a tone pair for lines 5–6 of "Inventory" ("It is good to be useful. It is good / to know where everything is.") and justify it with one feature of the syntax.

Check your reasoning. "Composed but strained" works. The short, repeated sentence pattern "It is good . . . It is good" sounds like self-reassurance, a speaker steadying himself or herself with a rule. "Content" alone misses the strain that the repetition and the later admission reveal.

Track how the speaker changes

Many poems are built on a change in the speaker's understanding, feeling or address. Common signals include:

  • a stanza break or the turn between parts of a sonnet;
  • a contrasting word such as "but," "yet," "still" or "now";
  • a change in tense, from past memory to present reflection;
  • a change in addressee, or the first appearance of "you";
  • a question, a command or a sudden shortening or lengthening of sentences;
  • a move from description to judgment.

Describe a shift as a movement from one position to another, with evidence on both sides. In "Inventory," the movement runs from controlled cataloguing (lines 1–6: counting, wiping, rows, rules about usefulness) to admitted attachment (lines 8–10: light, "that summer," "her talking"). The hinge is line 7, where the listener's question breaks the speaker's routine. A strong answer names all three parts: the first position, what triggers the change and the second position.

Common error. "The speaker goes from happy to sad." This names two moods without showing what changes or why. Replace it with something like: "The speaker moves from using chores to keep feeling at a distance to letting a single image carry the feeling the chores were holding back."

Speaker questions on the examination

Before reading the choices, sketch the speaking situation in a phrase: "grieving relative answering a question in a cellar." Then test each choice against the poem's words. Watch for four wrong-answer patterns:

  • Speaker equals poet: a choice that attributes the experience to the poet's life.
  • Literal comparison: a choice that treats a simile or metaphor as a fact about the setting ("the speaker is at sea" when the sea appears only in a comparison).
  • Tone exaggeration: a choice that turns restraint into despair or admiration into worship.
  • Local detail as whole: a choice that describes one line accurately but misdescribes the poem's overall movement.

Choices beginning "The speaker's attitude shifts from . . ." must be right on both ends. Check the first term against the opening and the second against the ending.

Writing about a speaker

A poetry-analysis thesis about a speaker should state how the speaker's attitude develops, not only what it is. Three attempts at a thesis about "Inventory":

  • Topic only: "The poet uses imagery and repetition to show the speaker's feelings." This makes no claim and names the poet instead of the speaker.
  • Defensible but static: "The speaker misses the woman who left." True, but it does not explain how the poem develops the feeling.
  • Defensible and developed: "The speaker's careful inventory of jars at first keeps grief at the level of housekeeping, but a listener's question forces the speaker to answer with an image instead of a reason, so that the unopened jars become a way of preserving the summer itself."

The third thesis names the first stance, the trigger and the changed stance, which gives the essay a line of reasoning to follow through the poem.

Practice

Printed multiple-choice set: Questions 91–101 (11 questions). These questions use "Before a Painting," a complete 14-line sonnet by James Weldon Johnson from Fifty Years and Other Poems (1917), printed in full with line numbers. Before answering, write your five-question sketch of the speaking situation beside the poem, and mark where the speaker's attitude turns. Work untimed at first; later, allow about 13 minutes.

Written task 6: poetry analysis. The essay uses "Lucinda Matlock" by Edgar Lee Masters, from Spoon River Anthology (1915), printed with the prompt. Plan for about 10 minutes, with special attention to the moment the speaker's audience appears, and write for about 30 minutes. Use the two printed response pages and continue in a notebook if needed.

Solutions. Each explanation cites the decisive lines and explains why every wrong choice fails. The essay solution includes a complete sample response, row-by-row scoring commentary, other defensible approaches and common errors. Attempt all the work before reading the solutions, which are printed separately.

Diagnose your misses. Label each miss in your error log as speaker equals poet, literal comparison, tone exaggeration, local detail as whole or misread situation, then reread the section named in the item's repair reference.

Review later

In three days: Without notes, list the five situation questions and the six shift signals. Then reconstruct the speaking situation of "Before a Painting" from memory and check it against the poem.

In one week: Choose a poem from your class reading. Write a three-part shift statement (first position, trigger, second position) with one quotation for each part.

In three weeks: Before Chapter 19, revise the thesis of your Written task 6 essay so that it names the speaker's first stance, the turn and the changed stance. Chapter 10 next examines how a speaker's sentences move across line breaks.

Use this chapter companion

Review the lesson, attempt the original practice, then check the explanation. Your printed study guide remains complete without the website.

Independence

Skill by Skill Prep is independent. SAT® and AP® are trademarks registered by the College Board, which is not affiliated with, and does not endorse, this website or book. PSAT/NMSQT® is a registered trademark of the College Board and the National Merit Scholarship Corporation, which are not affiliated with, and do not endorse, this site. Bluebook™ is a trademark of the College Board. ACT® is a trademark of ACT Education Corp., which is not affiliated with and does not endorse this website or book. Desmos is a trademark of Desmos Studio PBC. Practice results describe these questions, not official scores or admission predictions.

Last updated .