What to practice
- Trace the meaningful relationship in simile, metaphor, personification and extended comparison.
Naming a comparison earns nothing yet
Poets compare because one thing can make another visible. A comparison asks you to carry qualities from something familiar to something harder to see: a feeling, a person, a stage of life, a relationship. When you write “the poet uses a simile,” you have only reported that a comparison exists. Reasoning begins when you explain which qualities travel, why those qualities matter in this poem, and what you understand differently because the poet chose them.
The AP course framework treats comparison as one of its seven skill categories, and it carries roughly 10 to 13 percent of the multiple-choice section (AP English Literature course framework). Questions in this category ask what a simile “suggests,” what a metaphor “emphasizes” or what a comparison “contributes.” On the poetry essay, a comparison counts as evidence only when your commentary explains its effect. This chapter gives you one routine for both situations, whether the comparison is a simile, metaphor, personification, allusion or extended comparison.
The three parts of every comparison
Every comparison has a subject, an image and a bridge.
- The subject is what the poem is actually talking about. Critics sometimes call it the tenor.
- The image is what the subject is compared to. Critics call it the vehicle.
- The bridge is the set of shared qualities that the context activates. It is never everything the subject and image have in common.
Consider this original practice line, written for this guide:
Her apology arrived like a late train.
The subject is the apology; the image is a late train. A train has many qualities: it is loud, heavy, made of steel, bound to a timetable, crowded with strangers. Only some cross the bridge. “Late” activates delay and the irritation of waiting. A train also arrives eventually, and it arrives because a schedule requires it. The line can therefore suggest that the apology was overdue, that the listener had been waiting, and perhaps that it came from obligation rather than impulse. It does not suggest that the apology was loud or made of metal. Choosing which qualities cross, and leaving the rest behind, is the skill.
Worked example: from label to explanation
Here is the same line analyzed at three levels.
| Level | Commentary | What it accomplishes |
|---|---|---|
| Label | “The writer uses a simile to describe the apology.” | Names the device. Explains nothing. |
| Paraphrase | “The simile shows the apology was late.” | Translates the image but adds nothing the word late did not already say. |
| Analysis | “Comparing the apology to a late train suggests that it was overdue and expected, something the listener had waited for and that came because it was owed rather than freely offered.” | Identifies the bridge, selects the activated qualities and states an implication about the relationship. |
The analytical version makes a claim that someone could dispute. Another reader might argue that a late train is still welcome when it finally pulls in. That disagreement shows the commentary is doing interpretive work rather than restating the line.
Four forms, four questions
Forms of comparison differ in how openly they announce themselves, and each invites a slightly different question.
| Form | Signal | Question to ask | Common near miss |
|---|---|---|---|
| Simile | like, as, as if, than | What does the explicit comparison select, and what does like keep separate? | Treating the simile as decoration (“vivid imagery”). |
| Metaphor | identity: is, becomes, or a noun used for another thing | What is gained by claiming identity instead of resemblance? | Reading the image literally. |
| Personification | human actions, feelings or intentions given to a nonhuman thing | Whose feeling is being projected, and what does the projection reveal? | Assuming the object really has the feeling. |
| Extended or implied comparison | one image developed across lines, or a comparison whose subject is never named | How does the comparison change as it continues, and what must the reader infer? | Analyzing only the first instance. |
A simile keeps the two terms visibly apart; like admits that they differ. A metaphor collapses that distance. “My debt is a weight” claims identity: the debt does not merely resemble a weight but is felt as one, in the body. Personification makes the image a person. When a speaker calls the wind “spiteful,” the wind has no intentions; the speaker reads intention into it, and that reading tells you about the speaker. An allusion carries qualities from a familiar story into the poem.
An extended comparison returns to one image and develops it. An implied comparison never states both terms. A poem might describe a lighthouse for twenty lines without saying “I am like the lighthouse,” yet the title, the speaker’s emotion or the speaker’s claims to inside knowledge can make the second term hard to avoid. With an implied comparison, cite the details that make the connection necessary. Do not simply announce it.
The transfer test
Use these five steps whenever a question or prompt involves a comparison.
- Name both terms literally. What is the subject? What is the image? If the subject is never stated, write down what the details suggest it is and which lines suggest it.
- List the image’s qualities in this context. Verbs and adjectives near the image tell you which qualities are active.
- Select the qualities that cross the bridge. Point to the specific words that activate each one.
- Notice what does not transfer, or what resists. Some qualities are irrelevant; others create tension with the subject. A tension is often the most interesting part.
- State the implication. Finish the sentence “This comparison suggests that…” with a claim about the speaker, the situation or the poem’s developing meaning.
Worked example: a sustained metaphor
The following short poem was written for this guide as a practice text. It is not the work of a historical author.
My father’s workshop is a harbor now:
the saws asleep like boats with folded sails,
the lathe at anchor, rope coiled on a nail.
No one is sailing. Everything is safe.
Step 1. The subject is the father’s workshop; the image is a harbor. Line 1 states the metaphor openly.
Step 2. Harbors shelter boats, hold them still, protect them from weather, and serve as places of departure and return.
Step 3. The poem activates stillness and shelter. The saws are “asleep,” the lathe is “at anchor,” the rope is “coiled.” A simile inside the metaphor, “asleep like boats with folded sails,” extends the harbor into particular tools.
Step 4. A harbor is also where voyages begin, and the last line refuses that possibility: “No one is sailing.” The word “now” in line 1 implies that the workshop was once something else, busy and in use.
Step 5. The comparison suggests that the workshop’s safety is a form of loss. Its tools are protected because nobody uses them. Whether the father is absent, ill or dead, the poem does not say; it lets the metaphor carry the feeling. “Everything is safe” sounds reassuring alone, but after “No one is sailing” it reads as quiet grief.
A weak answer says, “The poet uses a metaphor to compare the workshop to a harbor.” A strong answer explains that the harbor metaphor turns stillness into an ambiguous safety, protective and mournful at once.
Worked example: an allusion
An allusion, a reference to a known text, figure or event, is a comparison whose image is a story the reader already knows. Original practice sentence: She called her first apartment the Ark: two of everything, and the rain had not started yet. The subject is the apartment; the image is Noah’s ark in Genesis. “Two of everything” carries over the ark’s careful pairing, and “the rain had not started yet” carries over its purpose, shelter from a coming flood. What resists is the scale: no flood threatens a first apartment, so the allusion is half a joke. It suggests a refuge furnished with hope and some anxious foresight.
When a comparison develops
Extended comparisons rarely stand still. Track three kinds of movement.
Escalation. Later instances intensify earlier ones. A speaker who first compares grief to rain and later to a flood has changed scale, and the change signals that the grief has grown or that the speaker is finally admitting its size.
Shift of focus. The same image is examined from a new angle. A poem might treat a lamp first as a source of light and later as a source of heat, so a later stanza discovers a quality the first ignored.
Reversal. The poem redefines what its image means. If early stanzas lead you to hear a song as joyful and a later stanza calls it a cry, the comparison has turned against your expectation.
When you analyze an extended comparison, write about its development: “At first the comparison suggests…, but by the final stanza it suggests…, because….” That sentence shape forces you to account for change.
Worked example: tracking one image across stanzas
This original practice poem uses a single image throughout.
The kite is mine; I run, and it obeys,
a red word written on the patient sky.
The wind decides. I learn the string’s small pull,
how much it wants, how little I can give.
I let the spool unwind to the last turn.
It holds. I hold. Neither of us is free.
In the first stanza the kite is a possession: it is “mine,” and it “obeys.” The metaphor “a red word written on the patient sky” makes the kite the speaker’s message, fully under the speaker’s control. In the second stanza control shifts: “The wind decides.” The string’s pull is given human desire (“how much it wants”), so the kite becomes a separate will. In the third stanza the speaker releases all the string and discovers mutual dependence: “It holds. I hold. Neither of us is free.” The comparison has moved from ownership to negotiation to a bond that constrains both partners. If the kite stands for a relationship, perhaps with a growing child, the poem never needs to say so; the image’s development carries the argument.
Six near misses and their repairs
- Decoration. “The simile creates vivid imagery.” Every simile is an image. Repair: name what the image helps you understand about the subject.
- Literalizing. Treating the image as the poem’s real subject: “The poem is about a harbor.” Repair: return to step 1 and name both terms.
- Total transfer. Carrying over every quality: “Because the speaker is compared to a bird, the speaker can fly.” Repair: transfer only the qualities the context activates, and cite the activating words.
- Symbol dictionary. “Birds always represent freedom.” Images have no fixed meaning across all poems. Repair: build the meaning from this poem’s verbs, adjectives and situation.
- Biography as proof. “The poet was unhappy, so the comparison shows the poet’s unhappiness.” A poem’s speaker is a constructed voice. Repair: support every claim about the speaker with lines from the poem. Outside facts can be context, never a substitute for textual evidence.
- Device list. “The poet uses simile, metaphor and personification.” Three labels are not three claims. Repair: organize commentary around stages of an argument and use the comparisons as evidence for each stage.
Try it
Read this original practice couplet:
Grandmother’s letters come like winter birds:
few, plain, and staying when the bright ones leave.
Write two sentences: one that identifies the bridge and one that states an implication about the letters or the relationship.
Check your reasoning. The subject is the grandmother’s letters; the image is winter birds. The context activates three qualities: scarcity (“few”), plainness (“plain”) and endurance (“staying when the bright ones leave”). Winter birds remain after the showier summer birds depart. A strong implication: the letters are modest, but they are faithful, still arriving after more colorful correspondents have stopped writing. If you wrote that the letters are cold or sad because winter is cold, you transferred a quality the couplet never activates; “staying” points to loyalty, not chill.
From comparison to essay paragraph
On the poetry essay, a comparison becomes strong evidence when your commentary connects it to the prompt’s interpretive question. Build each body paragraph in four moves.
- Claim. Write a sentence about the speaker or the poem’s developing meaning, not about a device: “The speaker presents aging as a loss of song as well as of strength.”
- Evidence. Quote briefly, with line numbers, choosing words that carry the claim.
- Commentary. Put the transfer test into prose: what crosses the bridge, what resists, what it implies.
- Link. Explain how this stage prepares for, or complicates, the next stage of your argument.
Quote exactly, keeping the poet’s spelling and punctuation, and mark omissions with an ellipsis. Sophistication comes from explaining how a comparison develops or where its qualities pull against each other, not from adding technical terms.
Review and retrieval
- In three days: Without looking back, write the five steps of the transfer test. Then apply them to one comparison from the poems in Chapter 11.
- In a week: Reread your essay for Written task 9. Underline every sentence that only names a device, and rewrite one so that it states what the comparison transfers and why that matters.
- Before Chapter 13: Choose one comparison from “Sympathy” and describe its development in a single sentence beginning “At first…, but by the end….” Chapter 13 builds on this habit of tracking change across a whole poem.
- Error log: Record any comparison you literalized or over-transferred under “failure to connect technique to meaning” or “unsupported inference.”
Practice
The printed practice for this chapter follows the lesson.
- Multiple choice: Questions 124–134 use Paul Laurence Dunbar’s poem “Sympathy” (1899), printed in full with line numbers. Read the whole poem once for its literal situation before you answer, then apply the transfer test to each comparison a question names.
- Essay: Written task 9 is a poetry-analysis essay on William Shakespeare’s Sonnet 73 (1609). Using a different poem, it tests whether the routine transfers to a fresh text. Allow about 40 minutes, including about five for planning; two response pages follow.
Answers, full explanations, the scoring guide and a complete sample essay are in Answers, explanations and written responses at the back of the book, under Chapter 12. Attempt every item before you check. For each question you miss, name the step of the transfer test that failed: the wrong subject, a quality the context did not activate, a missed tension or a missing implication.