Explain patterns across a longer work

Relate beginnings, recurring images, subplots, climaxes and endings without reducing the work to plot summary.

What to practice

  • Relate beginnings, recurring images, subplots, climaxes and endings without reducing the work to plot summary.

A novel or play is too long to hold in mind all at once. Readers hold it through patterns: an object that returns, a kind of scene that happens again, a minor plot that repeats the main one in a different key, an ending that answers the opening. This chapter teaches you to find those patterns and to explain what they do. That explanation is the difference between analysis and plot summary. A summary reports that one thing happened and then another. A pattern claim argues that the second event changes how we understand the first, and that the change matters to the meaning of the whole work.

You will use this skill in two places. On the multiple-choice section, a longer-fiction or drama passage is an excerpt, and its questions ask what the excerpt establishes. On the third essay, you argue about a whole work that you choose.

What counts as a pattern

A pattern is a repetition with a difference. The same element appears at two or more points, and something about it has changed: its context, who notices it, what it costs or what it promises. Apply three tests before you build an argument on a pattern.

  1. Recurrence. The element appears at clearly different points in the work, not in two neighboring sentences.
  2. Variation. Something about the element is different when it returns. Exact repetition can matter too, but then the difference lies in the circumstances around it.
  3. Consequence. The change alters how you understand a character, a conflict or the question the work keeps asking.

"Rain appears many times in the novel" passes only the first test. "Rain falls at the wedding and again at the funeral, so the weather that once seemed a nuisance becomes a sign that the family's celebrations and its losses belong to one history" passes all three. The stronger sentence still begins with an observation. Analysis does not skip the noticing; it finishes it.

Worked example: a bell in three places

The following extracts were written for this guide as practice. They come from three points in an imagined novel about a family hardware shop.

Opening. Every morning Ruth's father unlocked the shop and rang the brass bell over the door twice, for luck. The street answered with footsteps.

Middle. After the bank's letter came, he stopped ringing it. Customers who still came in set it jangling themselves, and he flinched at the sound as if someone had read a bill aloud.

Ending. On the last day Ruth took the bell down, wrapped it in newspaper and carried it to the new apartment, where there was no door for it to hang above.

A ledger keeps the comparison honest.

PointWhat the bell doesWho controls itWhat it seems to mean here
OpeningRings twice; the street respondsThe fatherA daily ritual of hope; shop and street call and answer
MiddleRings when customers enterThe customersA reminder of debt; the father no longer owns the sound
EndingSilent, wrapped, without a doorRuthA keepsake; the shop survives only as private memory

A weak claim names a symbol: "The bell represents the shop." A stronger claim follows the change: "The bell moves from ritual to reproach to keepsake. As the father loses control of its sound, the shop's public life shrinks into memory, and Ruth's decision to keep a bell that has no door suggests that the family can preserve its identity only by removing it from the world that once answered it."

Now test the claim against a resistant detail. Customers "still came in" during the middle extract, so the shop has not lost everyone. The claim survives if it concerns the father's experience of the sound rather than the shop's finances. Revise accordingly: the bell records what the shop has become to him, which is not quite what it has become to the street. That adjustment makes the claim more precise, and precision is what persuades a reader.

Four places where patterns form

Beginnings set the terms

The opening of a longer work introduces its first questions, oppositions and promises. Read it for what is about to happen (an arrival, a birth, a decision), what is mentioned more than once, what is withheld and who has the authority to tell the story. These are not predictions of the plot. They are the terms in which later events will be measured.

An opening can also move between times. A scene in the present may pause for a character's memories and then return, so that the history shapes how we read the moment. When a passage does this, ask what the return to the present makes newly urgent.

On the exam, a longer-fiction passage is often an excerpt from the beginning or middle of a novel. Answer only from the passage. If you know how the novel ends, set that knowledge aside: a question about what an opening "establishes" or "suggests" is answered by details printed in front of you. Hindsight is a common way for strong readers to miss straightforward questions.

Recurring images, objects and places

Track an image by its contexts, not by a dictionary of symbols. Green does not mean envy, water does not mean rebirth and a window does not mean freedom until the work makes it do so. Each time the element returns, ask three questions. Who perceives it? What has happened since its last appearance? Has its value risen or fallen?

Patterns operate at more than one scale. Within a single exam passage, a smell, the weather or a room can join a pattern: three references to heat, or several images of death gathered around a hopeful event, can shape the mood of a scene and the stakes of its outcome. Across a novel, a pattern may span hundreds of pages. Figurative language can belong to a pattern as well. If a narrator describes a hope as having "died," and the scene concerns a birth that may end in death, the metaphor repeats the scene's central opposition in a smaller form.

Subplots and parallel characters

A subplot often tests the main plot's question under different conditions. Suppose a novel's main plot follows a daughter who stays to run the family farm, while a subplot follows a neighbor's son who leaves for the city and returns in debt. A careless reader concludes that the subplot proves leaving is a mistake. A careful reader asks what the subplot lets the work examine that the main plot cannot: perhaps the cost of a choice the daughter never gets to make, or the community's eagerness to turn one failure into a lesson. Parallel characters work the same way. When two characters face a similar choice, their different responses make the choice itself visible.

Climaxes and endings

An ending answers the opening in one of three broad ways. It can confirm an early expectation, reverse it, or complicate it so that the original question looks incomplete. Do not treat the ending as a moral attached to the story ("He dies, which shows that greed is bad"). Ask what the ending does to elements that appeared earlier. If an object from the first chapter returns in the last, its final appearance is strong evidence, because the whole work stands between its two appearances.

Worked example: a pattern across a whole novel

F. Scott Fitzgerald's The Great Gatsby (1925) contains a pattern that can be traced through three scenes. Quotations come from Project Gutenberg eBook #64317. If you have not read the novel, follow the method rather than the details.

Summary version. Gatsby throws huge parties, Tom and Daisy attend one, and after Gatsby dies almost no one comes to his funeral.

Pattern version.

SceneWhat the gathering looks likeWhat it reveals
Chapter III"In his blue gardens men and girls came and went like moths among the whisperings and the champagne and the stars."The simile makes the guests moths drawn to light; they come for the display, not for Gatsby.
Chapter VIAt the party she attends, Daisy "was appalled by West Egg."The gathering meant to win Daisy repels her, so the parties fail at their one private purpose.
Chapter IXAt the funeral, "Nobody came." The owl-eyed guest from the first party exclaims that "they used to go there by the hundreds."The last gathering is an empty version of the first, and the one returning guest measures the difference.

Claim. The gatherings shrink from a crowd to a handful, and the shrinking exposes what the crowd had always been: people attracted by display and not bound to the man who paid for it. The pattern turns the parties from evidence of Gatsby's success into evidence of his isolation.

The claim works because it joins three moments, explains the change and connects the change to an interpretation of Gatsby. It does not need every party in the novel. It needs well-chosen points that show the direction of change.

Common errors and repairs

  • The tour guide. "The bell appears at the opening, the middle and the end." Repair: after each appearance, write what is different and why it matters.
  • The decoder. "The green light symbolizes money." Repair: show how the work builds a meaning in context, and allow that meaning to change.
  • Hindsight. Answering a question about an opening with events from later chapters. Repair: underline the words in the excerpt that support your answer. If you cannot find any, choose again.
  • The moral tag. "In the end she leaves, which teaches us to be independent." Repair: explain what the ending does to earlier elements.
  • The ignored subplot. Treating secondary characters as background. Repair: ask what question the subplot tests that the main plot cannot.

Try it

Task 1. The following extracts were written for this guide. They come from three points in an imagined novel.

Chapter 1. The new teacher hung her mother's map on the classroom wall. The children asked which places she had visited, and she said, "Not yet."

Chapter 9. She lent the map to the school board for a meeting about closing the school. It came back with three towns circled in pencil.

Chapter 20. On her last morning she rolled up the map, left it on the desk for the next teacher and erased only one of the circles.

Write a one-sentence claim about how the map's significance changes. Then name one detail that limits your claim.

Check your reasoning. One defensible claim: the map changes from a private emblem of the teacher's hopes ("Not yet") into an instrument of the board's decisions, and her choice to leave it while erasing one circle suggests a partial reclaiming of a future she can no longer control. The limiting detail is that she erases only one circle. The claim should not say she undoes the board's plans or recovers her original hope. If your claim said that the map "symbolizes travel," it named a topic rather than a change.

Task 2. Read this opening sentence, written for this guide: "The Larkin house had been sold three times in ten years, and each family had painted over the same water stain on the dining-room ceiling." List two things the sentence establishes and one question it makes a reader carry forward.

Check your reasoning. It establishes unstable ownership (three sales in ten years) and a repeated act of concealment (painting over the same stain). It raises the question of what causes the stain and why no family repairs it. A strong answer does not predict the plot. It names the terms that later events will test.

Reading the chapter passage

The printed practice uses the opening of Charles W. Chesnutt's novel The Marrow of Tradition (1901), a novel about race and power in a Southern city after the Civil War. The opening introduces a white family, the Carterets, and Jane, the elderly Black woman who nursed Olivia Carteret as a child. Before answering, list three things the opening establishes, mark every reference to birth, death, the family name or the past, and note what Jane promises to explain. Jane's speech is rendered in dialect spelling; read it aloud slowly if it is unfamiliar. Treat the narrator's descriptions of every character as part of the text you are analyzing. Answer only from the passage. The questions do not require knowledge of later chapters.

Plan a whole-work pattern essay

For the essay, choose a work you have read completely, not one you know only from a summary or a film. Build a short ledger before you write.

Point in the workWhat recursWhat has changedHow the change answers the prompt
Early
Middle
Late

Choose points that show the direction of change. Your thesis should name the element, the change and what the change reveals about the whole work. Organize body paragraphs by stages of the argument, not by a list of devices. Quote only what you remember exactly. Accurate paraphrase of a specific scene earns credit; an invented quotation weakens it.

Practice

Complete the printed chapter practice after this lesson.

  • Questions 166–176 (11 multiple-choice questions) use the opening of The Marrow of Tradition. Allow about 15 minutes, and write a brief reason beside each answer.
  • Written task 13 is a literary argument essay about a work you choose. Allow 40 minutes, including about 8 minutes to complete a pattern ledger.

Answers, explanations, a scoring guide and a complete sample essay appear in "Answers, explanations and written responses," under Chapter 16. Each explanation ends with a repair reference to a heading in this chapter.

Review later

  • In three days: without notes, rebuild the ledger for the bell example and restate its claim. Then compare your version with this chapter.
  • In one week: choose a work you know well and write a three-row ledger for one recurring element. Revise your thesis after naming a detail that resists it.
  • In three weeks: redo any multiple-choice question you missed, and explain in writing why your original answer lacked support in the passage.

Use this chapter companion

Review the lesson, attempt the original practice, then check the explanation. Your printed study guide remains complete without the website.

Independence

Skill by Skill Prep is independent. SAT® and AP® are trademarks registered by the College Board, which is not affiliated with, and does not endorse, this website or book. PSAT/NMSQT® is a registered trademark of the College Board and the National Merit Scholarship Corporation, which are not affiliated with, and do not endorse, this site. Bluebook™ is a trademark of the College Board. ACT® is a trademark of ACT Education Corp., which is not affiliated with and does not endorse this website or book. Desmos is a trademark of Desmos Studio PBC. Practice results describe these questions, not official scores or admission predictions.

Last updated .