Interpret rates and one-dimensional motion

Explain position, velocity, acceleration and non-motion rates

What to practice

  • Explain position, velocity, acceleration and non-motion rates

A derivative is a rate, and every rate has a context: what changes, with respect to what, and in which units. This chapter covers topics 4.1 to 4.3 of the course framework: derivatives in context, motion along a line, and rates in other settings. Two habits return in every later unit: state units, and keep direction separate from speed.

Predict before you read

Answer quickly; the chapter settles each one.

  1. At one instant a particle has velocity −2-2 and acceleration 44. Is it speeding up?
  2. P(t)P(t) counts people and tt is measured in hours. What are the units of P′(t)P'(t)?
  3. Can an object with negative acceleration be speeding up?

Read a derivative as a sentence

If y=f(x)y=f(x), then f′(a)f'(a) is the instantaneous rate of change of yy with respect to xx at x=ax=a. Its units are always output units per input unit, so P′(t)P'(t) in the second prediction is in people per hour. A complete interpretation answers four questions: at what input, which quantity, increasing or decreasing, and how fast, in which units. One template:

At [input value with units], [output quantity] is [increasing or decreasing] at a rate of [size of the derivative] [output units] per [input unit].

The sign carries the direction, so write "decreasing at 0.08", not "increasing at −0.08-0.08". It also approximates change: one more input unit changes the output by about f′(a)f'(a) units, not exactly, because the rate may vary.

The second derivative has units of output per input per input; its sign tells whether the rate, not the quantity, is rising.

Example 9.1: a rate whose input is not time

A car's tank holds S(m)S(m) liters of fuel after the car has driven mm kilometers on a trip. Interpret S′(120)=−0.08S'(120)=-0.08 and S′′(120)=0.0002S''(120)=0.0002.

Solution. The input is distance, so the rate is per kilometer, not per hour. After 120 kilometers, the fuel in the tank is decreasing at 0.08 liter per kilometer driven; the next kilometer uses about 0.08 liter.

The units of S′′(120)S''(120) are liters per kilometer per kilometer. Because it is positive, S′S' is increasing toward 0, so each kilometer uses slightly less fuel than the one before. The fuel itself is still decreasing.

Common error. Writing "liters per hour" because many rates involve time. Read the input variable before you write units.

Position, velocity and acceleration

For a particle moving along a line with position x(t)x(t):

  • velocity is v(t)=x′(t)v(t)=x'(t), and acceleration is a(t)=v′(t)=x′′(t)a(t)=v'(t)=x''(t);
  • v(t)>0v(t)>0 means motion in the positive direction, and v(t)<0v(t)<0 means motion in the negative direction;
  • speed is ∣v(t)∣|v(t)|, which is never negative;
  • the particle changes direction where v(t)v(t) changes sign. A zero of vv without a sign change is only a momentary stop.

Displacement over [a,b][a,b] is x(b)−x(a)x(b)-x(a). Total distance traveled adds the length of every leg, so split the interval wherever the direction changes.

Example 9.2: a complete motion analysis

A particle's position is x(t)=t3−9t2+24tx(t)=t^{3}-9t^{2}+24t meters for 0≤t≤50 \leq t \leq 5 seconds. Describe its motion, and find its displacement and total distance traveled.

Solution. Differentiate twice:

v(t)=3t2−18t+24=3(t−2)(t−4)v(t)=3t^{2}-18t+24=3(t-2)(t-4)

a(t)=6t−18=6(t−3)a(t)=6t-18=6(t-3)

The velocity is zero at t=2t=2 and t=4t=4, and its sign changes at each:

Interval(0,2)(0,2)(2,4)(2,4)(4,5)(4,5)
Sign of vv++−-++
Directionpositivenegativepositive

The positions at the endpoints and turning points are x(0)=0x(0)=0, x(2)=20x(2)=20, x(4)=16x(4)=16 and x(5)=20x(5)=20.

  • Displacement: x(5)−x(0)=20x(5)-x(0)=20 meters.
  • Total distance: ∣20−0∣+∣16−20∣+∣20−16∣=20+4+4=28|20-0|+|16-20|+|20-16|=20+4+4=28 meters.

Figure 9.1 shows the same analysis in three linked graphs. The direction reverses where the position graph has a horizontal tangent, which is where the velocity graph crosses the axis.

Three stacked graphs on one time axis from 0 to 5 seconds. Position rises from 0 to 20 at t equals 2, falls to 16 at t equals 4 and rises to 20 at t equals 5. Velocity is an upward-opening parabola, positive before t equals 2, negative from 2 to 4 and positive after 4. Acceleration is a rising line crossing zero at t equals 3. The intervals from 2 to 3 and from 4 to 5 are hatched.

Figure 9.1. Position, velocity and acceleration for Example 9.2 on one time axis. The hatched intervals are where velocity and acceleration have the same sign.

Common error. Reporting ∣x(5)−x(0)∣=20|x(5)-x(0)|=20 as the total distance. That is the displacement; it ignores the 4-meter backward leg and the 4-meter return.

Speeding up and slowing down

Three signs answer three different questions.

Sign to checkQuestion it answers
Sign of vvWhich way is the particle moving?
Sign of aaIs the velocity increasing or decreasing?
Signs of vv and aa togetherIs the speed increasing or decreasing?

Speed increases when vv and aa have the same sign and decreases when they have opposite signs. To see why, suppose v<0v<0 and a<0a<0. The velocity is decreasing, so it becomes more negative, and its distance from zero, the speed, grows. So negative acceleration does not mean slowing down, which settles the third prediction. In the first prediction, v=−2v=-2 and a=4a=4 have opposite signs, so that particle is slowing down.

In Example 9.2, a<0a<0 on (0,3)(0,3) and a>0a>0 on (3,5)(3,5). Combining signs, the particle slows down on (0,2)(0,2) and (3,4)(3,4) and speeds up on (2,3)(2,3) and (4,5)(4,5), the hatched intervals in Figure 9.1.

Example 9.3: from a velocity graph to a sign table

Figure 9.2 shows a velocity v(t)v(t), in meters per second, for 0≤t≤80 \leq t \leq 8 (solid) and the speed ∣v(t)∣|v(t)| (dashed). Without a formula, find where the particle speeds up.

A solid velocity curve from 0 to 8 seconds rises from 0 to 4 at t equals 2, falls through 0 at t equals 4 to negative 4 at t equals 6, and returns to 0 at t equals 8. A dashed speed curve matches it from 0 to 4 and mirrors it above the axis from 4 to 8. The intervals from 0 to 2 and from 4 to 6 are hatched.

Figure 9.2. Velocity (solid) and speed (dashed) for Example 9.3.

Solution. Read the sign of vv from the side of the axis, and the sign of aa from the slope of the velocity graph.

Interval(0,2)(0,2)(2,4)(2,4)(4,6)(4,6)(6,8)(6,8)
vv++++−-−-
aa (slope of vv)++−-−-++
Speedincreasingdecreasingincreasingdecreasing

The particle speeds up on (0,2)(0,2) and (4,6)(4,6): speed increases where a velocity graph moves away from the horizontal axis. On (4,6)(4,6) the graph falls, yet the speed rises, because the graph is moving away from the axis below it.

Example 9.4: diagnose a right answer with a wrong reason

For the particle in Example 9.2, a student writes: "At t=3.5t=3.5 the particle is slowing down because v(3.5)<0v(3.5)<0."

Diagnosis. Check the facts: v(3.5)=3(1.5)(−0.5)=−2.25v(3.5)=3(1.5)(-0.5)=-2.25 and a(3.5)=6(0.5)=3a(3.5)=6(0.5)=3. The signs are opposite, so the particle is slowing down. The conclusion is right, but the reason would earn no credit, because the sign of vv gives only the direction. Test the same reason at t=2.5t=2.5: v(2.5)=−2.25v(2.5)=-2.25 is also negative, but a(2.5)=−3a(2.5)=-3, so the particle is speeding up there.

Repair. "Slowing down, because v(3.5)=−2.25<0v(3.5)=-2.25<0 and a(3.5)=3>0a(3.5)=3>0 have opposite signs."

When a calculator is required

If a velocity formula needs a calculator, work in radian mode: evaluate v(t)v(t), compute a(t)=v′(t)a(t)=v'(t) numerically, write both values with their signs, and only then conclude. Report three decimal places.

Rates in other contexts

Every rule above carries over when the input is not time, as with temperature against depth or cost against items produced. Name the input and its unit first; the rate is "per" that unit.

When a function is known only from a table, estimate its derivative with a difference quotient. For an input cc between two table inputs p<c<qp<c<q, use

f′(c)≈f(q)−f(p)q−pf'(c)\approx \frac{f(q)-f(p)}{q-p}

and choose the closest table inputs on either side of cc. This is only an estimate of f′(c)f'(c).

Example 9.5: choose the estimate a table supports

The table gives the water temperature T(h)T(h), in degrees Celsius, at depth hh meters in a lake (constructed practice data). TT is differentiable. Estimate T′(6)T'(6) and interpret it.

hh (meters)025810
T(h)T(h) (°C)242215109

Solution. The table has no entry for 6. The closest depths on either side are 5 and 8:

T′(6)≈T(8)−T(5)8−5=10−153=−53≈−1.667T'(6)\approx \frac{T(8)-T(5)}{8-5}=\frac{10-15}{3}=-\frac{5}{3}\approx -1.667

At a depth of 6 meters, the temperature is decreasing by about 1.667 °C per meter of additional depth.

Why not use the whole table? The quotient 9−2410−0=−1.5\frac{9-24}{10-0}=-1.5 is the average rate over the whole lake, mixing slow change near the surface with fast change in the middle layer. The narrowest interval around 6 is the best-supported estimate.

Example 9.6: connect two rates with units

A diver descends at 0.5 meter per second and passes a depth of 6 meters. Using Example 9.5, about how fast is the water temperature around the diver changing with respect to time?

Solution. Temperature depends on depth, and depth depends on time, so the chain rule links the rates:

dTdt=dTdh⋅dhdt≈(−53)(0.5)=−56≈−0.833\frac{dT}{dt}=\frac{dT}{dh}\cdot\frac{dh}{dt}\approx\left(-\frac{5}{3}\right)(0.5)=-\frac{5}{6}\approx -0.833

Check the units: degrees per meter times meters per second gives degrees per second. The water around the diver is cooling at about 0.833 °C per second.

Try it

Try it 9.1. The monthly rent for an apartment with aa square feet of floor space is R(a)R(a) dollars. (a) Interpret R′(800)=1.9R'(800)=1.9 with units. (b) If R(800)=1450R(800)=1450, estimate the rent for an 810-square-foot apartment.

Try it 9.2. A particle's position is x(t)=2t3−3t2−12t+1x(t)=2t^{3}-3t^{2}-12t+1 meters for 0≤t≤40 \leq t \leq 4 seconds. (a) When does it change direction? (b) On which intervals is it speeding up? (c) Find its total distance traveled.

Try it 9.3. A tank holds V(t)V(t) liters of water at time tt minutes, with V′(10)=−3V'(10)=-3 and V′′(10)=0.4V''(10)=0.4. A student writes: "At t=10t=10 the water is draining more and more slowly, because V′′(10)>0V''(10)>0. Also, the tank holds exactly 3 liters less at t=10t=10 than at t=9t=9." Evaluate both claims.

Check your work

9.1. (a) When the floor space is 800 square feet, the rent increases by about 1.90 dollars per additional square foot. (b) R(810)≈1450+1.9(10)=1469R(810)\approx 1450+1.9(10)=1469 dollars. It is approximate, because the rate may vary.

9.2. v(t)=6t2−6t−12=6(t−2)(t+1)v(t)=6t^{2}-6t-12=6(t-2)(t+1) and a(t)=12t−6=6(2t−1)a(t)=12t-6=6(2t-1). (a) On [0,4][0,4], v<0v<0 before t=2t=2 and v>0v>0 after, so the particle changes direction only at t=2t=2; the zero at t=−1t=-1 is outside the interval. (b) It speeds up on (0,0.5)(0,0.5), where both signs are negative, and on (2,4)(2,4), where both are positive. It slows down on (0.5,2)(0.5,2). (c) x(0)=1x(0)=1, x(2)=−19x(2)=-19 and x(4)=33x(4)=33, so the distance is 20+52=7220+52=72 meters.

9.3. The first conclusion is right, but its reason is incomplete. Draining means V′(10)<0V'(10)<0, and V′′(10)>0V''(10)>0 means V′V' is increasing toward 0, so the draining rate of 3 liters per minute is shrinking. Both signs are needed. The second claim is wrong: V′(10)=−3V'(10)=-3 is an instantaneous rate, so the change over the minute before t=10t=10 is only approximately 3 liters.

Review and retrieve

  • A derivative's units are output units per input unit.
  • The sign of vv gives direction; speed increases exactly when vv and aa share a sign.
  • Direction changes need a sign change of vv, not just a zero.
  • Total distance splits at turning points; displacement does not.
  • From a table, use the closest inputs on either side, and say "approximately".

Retrieve. In two days, without notes, rebuild Example 9.2's sign tables and speeding-up intervals. A week later, redo Try it 9.2(c) for 0≤t≤30 \leq t \leq 3. Check: x(3)=−8x(3)=-8, so the distance is 20+11=3120+11=31 meters.

Practice

Work items APCAL-C09-M01 to APCAL-C09-M12, printed after this chapter's companion panel as Questions 110–121. Do Questions 110–116 without a calculator. Questions 117–121 require a graphing calculator in radian mode; report three decimal places unless a question says otherwise.

Then complete the two written tasks, APCAL-C09-F01 (Written task 10, graphing calculator required) and APCAL-C09-F02 (Written task 11, no calculator), using the two response pages printed for each.

Full solutions, an explanation of every wrong choice, nine-point rubrics and complete sample responses are in Answers, explanations and written responses at the back of the book, under Chapter 9: answers and explanations. Each explanation ends with a Repair and retry line pointing to a section of this chapter.

Use this chapter companion

Review the lesson, attempt the original practice, then check the explanation. Your printed study guide remains complete without the website.

Independence

Skill by Skill Prep is independent. SAT® and AP® are trademarks registered by the College Board, which is not affiliated with, and does not endorse, this website or book. PSAT/NMSQT® is a registered trademark of the College Board and the National Merit Scholarship Corporation, which are not affiliated with, and do not endorse, this site. Bluebook™ is a trademark of the College Board. ACT® is a trademark of ACT Education Corp., which is not affiliated with and does not endorse this website or book. Desmos is a trademark of Desmos Studio PBC. Practice results describe these questions, not official scores or admission predictions.

Last updated .