Model related rates, approximation, and indeterminate limits

Build variable relationships and check approximation or limit conditions

What to practice

  • Build variable relationships and check approximation or limit conditions

This chapter covers topics 4.4 to 4.7 of the course framework: rates linked by an equation, approximating a function by its tangent line, and L'Hospital's rule for limits of the forms 00\frac{0}{0} and ∞∞\frac{\infty}{\infty}. One habit joins them: check the conditions before you compute. Related rates need an equation that holds at every instant. A tangent-line estimate needs a stated center and a concavity check. L'Hospital's rule needs an eligible form.

Predict before you read

  1. A runner's distance xx from a pole is changing. If you substitute today's value of xx before differentiating, what derivative will you get for x2x^{2}?
  2. Does a concave-up graph lie above or below its tangent lines?
  3. Does L'Hospital's rule apply to limx→2x2+43x−2\mathrm{lim}_{x\to 2}\frac{x^{2}+4}{3x-2}?

Related rates: relate first, then differentiate

When quantities that change with time are linked by an equation, their rates are linked by the derivative of that equation. Work in this order.

  1. Draw a diagram. Name each changing quantity as a function of time, and mark what stays constant.
  2. Write an equation that holds at every instant.
  3. Differentiate both sides with respect to tt. By the chain rule, each changing quantity brings its own rate.
  4. Only now substitute the values at the instant in question, and solve for the unknown rate.
  5. Give the answer with units, and say what its sign means.

Example 10.1: name what changes

A camera on top of a 12-meter pole tracks a runner who moves in a straight line away from the base of the pole at 5 meters per second. How fast is the distance from the camera to the runner increasing when the runner is 16 meters from the base?

Diagram of a vertical pole 12 meters tall with a camera on top. A dashed line of sight runs down to a runner on level ground. The ground distance from the base to the runner is labeled x of t, the line of sight s of t, and the angle at the runner between the ground and the line of sight theta of t. An arrow shows the runner moving away from the pole. A note lists x, s and theta as variables and 12 as a constant.

Figure 10.1. The camera problem with its changing quantities named. Only the pole's height is constant.

Solution. Let x(t)x(t) be the runner's distance from the base and s(t)s(t) the distance from the camera to the runner. We know x′(t)=5x'(t)=5 and want s′(t)s'(t) when x=16x=16. At every instant, the Pythagorean theorem gives

s2=x2+144s^{2}=x^{2}+144

Differentiate with respect to tt: 2s s′=2x x′2s\,s'=2x\,x', so s′=x x′ss'=\frac{x\,x'}{s}. At the instant, s=162+144=20s=\sqrt{16^{2}+144}=20, so

s′=16⋅520=4s'=\frac{16\cdot 5}{20}=4

The distance is increasing at 4 meters per second.

Example 10.2: diagnose an early substitution

A student writes s2=162+144=400s^{2}=16^{2}+144=400, so s=20s=20, and then: "The derivative of 20 is 0, so s′=0s'=0."

Diagnosis. Substituting x=16x=16 first froze a changing quantity. The equation s2=400s^{2}=400 is true at one instant only, and its derivative says nothing about how ss changes. That is the trap in the first prediction: substitute first and every derivative becomes 0. The answer also fails a reasonableness check, because a runner moving away must be getting farther from the camera.

Repair. Differentiate the relation that holds for all tt, s2=x2+144s^{2}=x^{2}+144, and substitute afterward, as in Example 10.1.

Example 10.3: choose the relation that uses known quantities

In the same setting, let θ(t)\theta(t) be the angle at the runner between the ground and the line of sight. How fast is θ\theta changing when x=16x=16?

Method choice. Three relations connect θ\theta to Figure 10.1: tan⁡θ=12x\tan\theta=\frac{12}{x}, sin⁡θ=12s\sin\theta=\frac{12}{s} and cos⁡θ=xs\cos\theta=\frac{x}{s}. The tangent relation involves only θ\theta and xx, whose rate is given. The sine relation needs s′s', which took a separate computation, and the cosine relation has two other changing quantities. Choose the tangent.

Solution. Differentiate tan⁡θ=12x−1\tan\theta=12x^{-1} with respect to tt:

sec⁡2θ⋅θ′=−12x2⋅x′\sec^{2}\theta\cdot\theta'=-\frac{12}{x^{2}}\cdot x'

At x=16x=16, tan⁡θ=34\tan\theta=\frac{3}{4}, so sec⁡2θ=1+916=2516\sec^{2}\theta=1+\frac{9}{16}=\frac{25}{16}. Then

θ′=−12⋅5256⋅1625=−0.15\theta'=-\frac{12\cdot 5}{256}\cdot\frac{16}{25}=-0.15

The angle is decreasing at 0.15 radian per second, as expected when the runner moves away. As a check, the sine relation gives cos⁡θ⋅θ′=−12 s′s2\cos\theta\cdot\theta'=-\frac{12\,s'}{s^{2}}, so 0.8 θ′=−0.120.8\,\theta'=-0.12 and θ′=−0.15\theta'=-0.15 again.

Common errors. Differentiating x2x^{2} as 2x2x instead of 2x x′2x\,x'; giving a shrinking quantity a positive rate; and treating a changing quantity as a constant, as in Example 10.2.

Example 10.4: eliminate a variable before differentiating

Water drains from a conical tank, vertex down, that is 6 meters tall with a top radius of 3 meters. Water leaves at 2 cubic meters per minute. How fast is the water level falling when the water is 4 meters deep?

Solution. The volume, depth hh and surface radius rr all change; the 6 and the 3 are constant. The volume formula V=13πr2hV=\frac{1}{3}\pi r^{2}h has two changing dimensions, but similar triangles give rh=36\frac{r}{h}=\frac{3}{6}, so r=h2r=\frac{h}{2} at every instant. Because that relation holds at every instant, you may substitute it before differentiating:

V=13π(h2)2h=πh312V=\frac{1}{3}\pi\left(\frac{h}{2}\right)^{2}h=\frac{\pi h^{3}}{12}

Differentiate: V′=πh24 h′V'=\frac{\pi h^{2}}{4}\,h'. At the instant, V′=−2V'=-2 and h=4h=4, so −2=4π h′-2=4\pi\,h' and h′=−12π≈−0.159h'=-\frac{1}{2\pi}\approx -0.159. The level is falling at about 0.159 meter per minute.

Compare Example 10.2. Substituting a relation that is true at every instant, such as r=h2r=\frac{h}{2}, is safe. Substituting a value that is true at one instant, such as h=4h=4, is not.

Local linearity

Near a point where ff is differentiable, the graph of ff looks almost straight, so its tangent line approximates ff. The tangent line at the center x=ax=a is

L(x)=f(a)+f′(a)(x−a)L(x)=f(a)+f'(a)(x-a)

and f(x)≈L(x)f(x)\approx L(x) for xx near aa. Always state the center and the estimate. To decide whether the estimate is too high or too low, check concavity on the whole interval between the center and the input.

  • If f′′>0f''>0 there, the graph is concave up and lies above the tangent line, so L(x)L(x) is an underestimate. This answers the second prediction.
  • If f′′<0f''<0 there, the graph is concave down and lies below the tangent line, so L(x)L(x) is an overestimate.

The sign of f′f' plays no part: an increasing function can be overestimated, and a decreasing one underestimated.

Often you are given f′f' rather than ff, as a graph or a table. Read the slope f′(a)f'(a) at the center from it, and read concavity from the behavior of f′f': if f′f' is increasing between the center and the input, ff is concave up there; if f′f' is decreasing, ff is concave down. Watch the sign of x−ax-a when the input is to the left of the center.

Example 10.5: an estimate and its direction from a table

A function gg is twice differentiable, and g′′(x)>0g''(x)>0 for 3≤x≤53 \leq x \leq 5. Use the table to estimate g(4.3)g(4.3) and g(3.8)g(3.8), and decide whether each estimate is too high or too low.

xxg(x)g(x)g′(x)g'(x)
42.5−0.6-0.6

Solution. The center is x=4x=4, so L(x)=2.5−0.6(x−4)L(x)=2.5-0.6(x-4). Then g(4.3)≈2.5−0.18=2.32g(4.3)\approx 2.5-0.18=2.32 and g(3.8)≈2.5+0.12=2.62g(3.8)\approx 2.5+0.12=2.62. Because g′′>0g''>0 on both intervals, the graph lies above its tangent line there, and both estimates are underestimates. Concavity, not the side of the center, decides the direction.

Example 10.6: see the error, and where the estimate breaks down

Let f(x)=4xf(x)=\frac{4}{x}. Since f(2)=2f(2)=2 and f′(2)=−422=−1f'(2)=-\frac{4}{2^{2}}=-1, the tangent line at x=2x=2 is L(x)=2−(x−2)=4−xL(x)=2-(x-2)=4-x, and f(2.5)≈1.5f(2.5)\approx 1.5. Since f′′(x)=8x3>0f''(x)=\frac{8}{x^{3}}>0 for x>0x>0, this is an underestimate. In fact f(2.5)=1.6f(2.5)=1.6 (Figure 10.2).

Graph of f of x equals 4 over x for x from 1 to 4, a decreasing curve, with its dashed tangent line y equals 4 minus x touching it at the point (2, 2). The curve lies above the tangent line everywhere shown. At x equals 2.5, a short vertical segment marks the gap between the curve value 1.6 and the tangent value 1.5. Near x equals 4 the tangent line falls to 0 while the curve is still at 1. A note states that the second derivative, 8 over x cubed, is positive, so the curve is concave up and above the tangent.

Figure 10.2. A concave-up graph lies above its tangent line, so tangent-line estimates are too low.

Farther from the center, the estimate degrades quickly: L(3.5)=0.5L(3.5)=0.5, but f(3.5)≈1.143f(3.5)\approx 1.143. A tangent line is a local tool; trust it only near its center.

L'Hospital's rule

Check the form first

L'Hospital's rule (also spelled L'Hôpital) evaluates a limit of a quotient whose numerator and denominator both approach 0, or both approach ±∞\pm\infty. Suppose ff and gg are differentiable near aa, except possibly at aa, that g′(x)≠0g'(x)\neq 0 near aa for x≠ax\neq a, and that f(x)g(x)\frac{f(x)}{g(x)} has the form 00\frac{0}{0} or ∞∞\frac{\infty}{\infty} as x→ax\to a. If limx→af′(x)g′(x)\mathrm{lim}_{x\to a}\frac{f'(x)}{g'(x)} exists, then

limx→af(x)g(x)=limx→af′(x)g′(x)\mathrm{lim}_{x\to a}\frac{f(x)}{g(x)}=\mathrm{lim}_{x\to a}\frac{f'(x)}{g'(x)}

The same holds for one-sided limits and for x→±∞x\to\pm\infty. The course assesses only the forms 00\frac{0}{0} and ∞∞\frac{\infty}{\infty}.

  • Differentiate the numerator and the denominator separately. This is not the quotient rule.
  • Write the check, for example "f(x)→0f(x)\to 0 and g(x)→0g(x)\to 0, so the form is 00\frac{0}{0}." On a free-response question, the check is part of the justification.
  • If the new limit is again 00\frac{0}{0} or ∞∞\frac{\infty}{\infty}, check again before applying the rule a second time.

Example 10.7: reject an ineligible limit

Evaluate limx→2x2+43x−2\mathrm{lim}_{x\to 2}\frac{x^{2}+4}{3x-2}.

Solution. Check the form first. The numerator approaches 8 and the denominator approaches 4, so this is not an indeterminate form, and the answer to the third prediction is no. The quotient is continuous at 2, so the limit is 84=2\frac{8}{4}=2. Applying the rule anyway gives limx→22x3=43\mathrm{lim}_{x\to 2}\frac{2x}{3}=\frac{4}{3}, which is wrong: the rule's conclusion cannot be used when its hypothesis fails.

Example 10.8: apply the rule and see why it works

Evaluate limx→0ex−cos⁡xsin⁡(3x)\mathrm{lim}_{x\to 0}\frac{e^{x}-\cos x}{\sin(3x)}.

Solution. As x→0x\to 0, the numerator approaches 1−1=01-1=0 and the denominator approaches sin⁡0=0\sin 0=0, so the form is 00\frac{0}{0}. Both functions are differentiable, and the denominator's derivative, 3cos⁡(3x)3\cos(3x), is not 0 near 0. So

limx→0ex−cos⁡xsin⁡(3x)=limx→0ex+sin⁡x3cos⁡(3x)=1+03=13\mathrm{lim}_{x\to 0}\frac{e^{x}-\cos x}{\sin(3x)}=\mathrm{lim}_{x\to 0}\frac{e^{x}+\sin x}{3\cos(3x)}=\frac{1+0}{3}=\frac{1}{3}

Figure 10.3 shows why the rule works. Near 0, each function stays close to its tangent line: the numerator behaves like xx and the denominator like 3x3x. Their ratio is close to x3x=13\frac{x}{3x}=\frac{1}{3}, the ratio of the derivatives at 0. L'Hospital's rule is local linearity applied to a quotient.

Graph for x from negative 0.4 to 0.4. Four curves pass through the origin: the numerator e to the x minus cosine x with its dotted tangent line y equals x, and the denominator sine of 3x with its dash-dot tangent line y equals 3x. Each curve stays close to its own tangent line near the origin. A note reads: near 0, numerator about x, denominator about 3x, ratio about one third.

Figure 10.3. Near x=0x=0, each function hugs its tangent line, so their ratio approaches the ratio of the tangent slopes.

When the values come from a table

Suppose f(a)=g(a)=0f(a)=g(a)=0, both functions have continuous derivatives, and g′(a)≠0g'(a)\neq 0. The form is 00\frac{0}{0}, and continuity of the derivatives lets you evaluate the new limit by substitution, so the limit of f(x)g(x)\frac{f(x)}{g(x)} as x→ax\to a is f′(a)g′(a)\frac{f'(a)}{g'(a)}. If instead f′(a)=g′(a)=0f'(a)=g'(a)=0, the new limit is again 00\frac{0}{0}; with continuous second derivatives and g′′(a)≠0g''(a)\neq 0, one more application gives f′′(a)g′′(a)\frac{f''(a)}{g''(a)}. Read only the rows the limit needs, and state each check.

The rule works in one direction only

If the limit of f′g′\frac{f'}{g'} does not exist, the rule says nothing. For example, limx→∞x+sin⁡xx\mathrm{lim}_{x\to\infty}\frac{x+\sin x}{x} has the form ∞∞\frac{\infty}{\infty}, but the derivative ratio 1+cos⁡x1\frac{1+\cos x}{1} oscillates between 0 and 2 without a limit. Yet x+sin⁡xx=1+sin⁡xx\frac{x+\sin x}{x}=1+\frac{\sin x}{x}, and sin⁡xx→0\frac{\sin x}{x}\to 0, so the original limit is 1. When the rule stalls, use algebra or another method.

Try it

Try it 10.1. A circular ink spot spreads so that its area increases at 6 square centimeters per second. How fast is the radius increasing when the radius is 4 centimeters?

Try it 10.2. Use the tangent line to y=ln⁡xy=\ln x at x=1x=1 to estimate ln⁡0.9\ln 0.9. Is the estimate too high or too low? Explain.

Try it 10.3. For each limit, first decide whether L'Hospital's rule applies, then evaluate. (a) limx→01−cos⁡xx2\mathrm{lim}_{x\to 0}\frac{1-\cos x}{x^{2}} (b) limx→0x+1ex\mathrm{lim}_{x\to 0}\frac{x+1}{e^{x}} (c) limx→∞3x2+5ex\mathrm{lim}_{x\to\infty}\frac{3x^{2}+5}{e^{x}}

Try it 10.4. The functions ff and gg have continuous derivatives, with f(5)=g(5)=0f(5)=g(5)=0, f′(5)=3f'(5)=3 and g′(5)=12g'(5)=12. Find limx→5f(x)g(x)\mathrm{lim}_{x\to 5}\frac{f(x)}{g(x)}, and state why the rule applies.

Check your work

10.1. A=πr2A=\pi r^{2}, so A′=2πr r′A'=2\pi r\,r'. At r=4r=4, 6=8π r′6=8\pi\,r', so r′=34π≈0.239r'=\frac{3}{4\pi}\approx 0.239 centimeter per second.

10.2. The center is x=1x=1, where ln⁡1=0\ln 1=0 and the slope is 11=1\frac{1}{1}=1. So L(x)=x−1L(x)=x-1 and ln⁡0.9≈−0.1\ln 0.9\approx -0.1. The second derivative of ln⁡x\ln x is −1x2<0-\frac{1}{x^{2}}<0, so the graph is concave down and lies below its tangent line: −0.1-0.1 is too high. The true value is about −0.105-0.105.

10.3. (a) The form is 00\frac{0}{0}. The rule gives sin⁡x2x\frac{\sin x}{2x}, again 00\frac{0}{0}; applying it again gives cos⁡x2→12\frac{\cos x}{2}\to\frac{1}{2}. (b) The quotient approaches 11\frac{1}{1}, which is not indeterminate, so the rule does not apply; the limit is 1 by substitution. (c) The form is ∞∞\frac{\infty}{\infty}. Two applications give 6xex\frac{6x}{e^{x}} and then 6ex→0\frac{6}{e^{x}}\to 0, so the limit is 0.

10.4. Both functions are continuous because they are differentiable, so f(x)→0f(x)\to 0 and g(x)→0g(x)\to 0: the form is 00\frac{0}{0}. Since g′(5)=12≠0g'(5)=12\neq 0 and g′g' is continuous, g′(x)≠0g'(x)\neq 0 near 5. The limit is f′(5)g′(5)=312=14\frac{f'(5)}{g'(5)}=\frac{3}{12}=\frac{1}{4}.

Review and retrieve

  • Related rates: name the changing quantities, write a relation true at every instant, differentiate with respect to tt, and only then substitute.
  • Choose the relation whose variables have known rates.
  • Tangent-line estimate: state the center aa and L(x)=f(a)+f′(a)(x−a)L(x)=f(a)+f'(a)(x-a). Concave up between the center and the input gives an underestimate; concave down gives an overestimate.
  • L'Hospital's rule: confirm 00\frac{0}{0} or ∞∞\frac{\infty}{\infty} and the hypotheses before differentiating, and differentiate top and bottom separately.

Retrieve. In two days, without notes, redo Example 10.1 with the runner 9 meters from the base. Check: s=15s=15 and s′=3s'=3 meters per second. A week later, list the checks you make before using L'Hospital's rule, and redo Example 10.5 assuming g′′<0g''<0 instead.

Practice

Work items APCAL-C10-M01 to APCAL-C10-M17, printed after this chapter's companion panel as Questions 122–138. Do Questions 122–132 without a calculator. Questions 133–138 require a graphing calculator in radian mode; report three decimal places unless a question says otherwise.

Then complete the two written tasks, APCAL-C10-F01 (Written task 12, graphing calculator required) and APCAL-C10-F02 (Written task 13, no calculator), using the two response pages printed for each.

Full solutions, an explanation of every wrong choice, nine-point rubrics and complete sample responses are in Answers, explanations and written responses at the back of the book, under Chapter 10: answers and explanations. Each explanation ends with a Repair and retry line pointing to a section of this chapter.

Use this chapter companion

Review the lesson, attempt the original practice, then check the explanation. Your printed study guide remains complete without the website.

Independence

Skill by Skill Prep is independent. SAT® and AP® are trademarks registered by the College Board, which is not affiliated with, and does not endorse, this website or book. PSAT/NMSQT® is a registered trademark of the College Board and the National Merit Scholarship Corporation, which are not affiliated with, and do not endorse, this site. Bluebook™ is a trademark of the College Board. ACT® is a trademark of ACT Education Corp., which is not affiliated with and does not endorse this website or book. Desmos is a trademark of Desmos Studio PBC. Practice results describe these questions, not official scores or admission predictions.

Last updated .