Justify extrema with theorems

Match hypotheses, candidates and conclusions in extrema arguments

What to practice

  • Match hypotheses, candidates and conclusions in extrema arguments

An argument about a maximum or minimum has three separate jobs. An existence theorem promises that something happens. Critical numbers and endpoints list where it could happen. A test decides what actually happens at each candidate. This chapter keeps the jobs apart, because most lost points come from merging two of them, such as calling every critical number an extremum or invoking a theorem whose conditions were never checked.

Predict first. If f′(5)=0f'(5)=0, must ff have a maximum or a minimum at x=5x=5? Write your answer down; Worked example 11.5 settles it.

What an existence theorem promises

The Mean Value Theorem (topic 5.1)

If ff is continuous on the closed interval [a,b][a,b] and differentiable on the open interval (a,b)(a,b), then there is at least one number cc in (a,b)(a,b) such that

f′(c)=f(b)−f(a)b−af'(c)=\frac{f(b)-f(a)}{b-a}

Somewhere strictly between the endpoints, the instantaneous rate of change equals the average rate of change over the whole interval. In a graph, some tangent line is parallel to the secant line through the endpoints. When f(a)=f(b)f(a)=f(b), the secant is horizontal and the conclusion becomes f′(c)=0f'(c)=0; this special case is called Rolle's Theorem.

The theorem promises existence only. It does not say where cc is, and several numbers may qualify.

Two side-by-side graphs. Left: the curve y equals the square root of x for x from 1 to 9, with a dashed secant line through (1, 1) and (9, 3) and a dotted tangent line touching the curve at (4, 2); the two lines are parallel, with slope one fourth. Right: the V-shaped graph of y equals the absolute value of x minus 2, plus 1, for x from 0 to 5, through (0, 3), a sharp corner at (2, 1), and (5, 4), with a dashed secant line through (0, 3) and (5, 4) of slope one fifth. The left branch has slope negative 1 and the right branch has slope 1, so no tangent is parallel to the secant.

Figure 11.1. Left: the Mean Value Theorem's hypotheses hold, and the tangent at x=4x=4 is parallel to the secant. Right: a corner breaks differentiability, and no tangent matches the secant slope.

The right panel is the warning. The function h(x)=∣x−2∣+1h(x)=|x-2|+1 is continuous on [0,5][0,5] but not differentiable at x=2x=2. Its secant slope is 15\frac{1}{5}, yet every slope of hh is −1-1 or 11. When a hypothesis fails, the theorem makes no promise.

Worked example 11.1: find the promised value. Apply the Mean Value Theorem to f(x)=xf(x)=\sqrt{x} on [1,9][1,9].

  1. Check the hypotheses first. x\sqrt{x} is continuous for x≥0x\geq 0 and differentiable for x>0x>0, so it is continuous on [1,9][1,9] and differentiable on (1,9)(1,9).
  2. Average rate: f(9)−f(1)9−1=3−18=14\frac{f(9)-f(1)}{9-1}=\frac{3-1}{8}=\frac{1}{4}.
  3. Solve f′(c)=12c=14f'(c)=\frac{1}{2\sqrt{c}}=\frac{1}{4}, so c=2\sqrt{c}=2 and c=4c=4.
  4. Check: 4 lies in the open interval (1,9)(1,9). Reject any solution at an endpoint or outside it.

The hypothesis check comes first because without it, the equation in step 3 may have no solution at all.

Worked example 11.2: from a table to a guarantee. A cyclist's odometer reads D(t)D(t) kilometers tt hours after 9:00 a.m. Assume DD is differentiable on [0,2][0,2].

tt (hours)00.52
D(t)D(t) (km)01454

Must the cyclist's speed have been exactly 27 km/h at some moment? Translate the table into a rate statement: the average rate over [0,2][0,2] is 54−02−0=27\frac{54-0}{2-0}=27 km/h. Differentiability on [0,2][0,2] gives continuity on [0,2][0,2] and differentiability on (0,2)(0,2), so the Mean Value Theorem guarantees some tt in (0,2)(0,2) with D′(t)=27D'(t)=27. Because an odometer never decreases, D′(t)D'(t) is the speed. So yes, although the table cannot say when. Over [0,0.5][0,0.5] the average rate is 28 km/h, which guarantees a moment at 28 km/h in that subinterval, not 27.

Common error. Citing the Intermediate Value Theorem. That theorem concerns values of DD itself, such as reaching 30 km between t=0.5t=0.5 and t=2t=2, and needs only continuity. The Mean Value Theorem concerns values of D′D'.

The Extreme Value Theorem (topic 5.2)

If ff is continuous on the closed interval [a,b][a,b], then ff has at least one maximum value and at least one minimum value on [a,b][a,b]. This wording follows the Fall 2026 clarification of the course framework. The guarantee is about values, not a unique location: a constant function attains its maximum at every input.

Both conditions matter. On (0,1](0,1], 1x\frac{1}{x} is continuous, but the interval is not closed and the function grows without bound, so it has no maximum. A jump can also leave a top value unattained. A failed hypothesis does not prove that the conclusion fails, however. A discontinuous function may still attain both extremes; the theorem is simply silent.

Try it 11.1. Decide whether the Mean Value Theorem applies, and whether the Extreme Value Theorem applies. (a) x1/3x^{1/3} on [−1,1][-1,1] (b) 1x−3\frac{1}{x-3} on [0,2][0,2] (c) tan⁡x\tan x on [0,π][0,\pi]

Solution. (a) Continuous on [−1,1][-1,1], so the EVT applies. The vertical tangent at 0 means no derivative there, so the MVT does not. (b) The only problem input, 3, lies outside [0,2][0,2], so both apply. (c) tan⁡x\tan x is undefined at π2\frac{\pi}{2}, so neither applies.

Critical numbers are candidates (topic 5.2)

A critical number of ff is a number cc in the domain of ff where f′(c)=0f'(c)=0 or f′(c)f'(c) does not exist. Every relative extremum at an interior point occurs at a critical number, but not every critical number is an extremum: x3x^3 has derivative 0 at x=0x=0 and keeps increasing through it.

Worked example 11.3: respect the domain. Find the critical numbers of f(x)=x2x−1f(x)=\frac{x^2}{x-1}. By the quotient rule,

f′(x)=2x(x−1)−x2(x−1)2=x(x−2)(x−1)2f'(x)=\frac{2x(x-1)-x^2}{(x-1)^2}=\frac{x(x-2)}{(x-1)^2}

f′(x)=0f'(x)=0 at x=0x=0 and x=2x=2, both in the domain, so both are critical numbers. f′f' is undefined at x=1x=1, but so is ff, so 1 is not a critical number. It still belongs on the sign chart, because ff can change behavior across a break in its domain.

Increasing, decreasing, and the First Derivative Test (topics 5.3 and 5.4)

If f′(x)>0f'(x)>0 for every xx in an open interval, ff is increasing there; if f′(x)<0f'(x)<0, decreasing. The sign of f′f' decides, not whether f′f' itself rises. To build a sign chart, mark every critical number and excluded input on a number line, then test one input in each piece.

First Derivative Test. Let cc be a critical number where ff is continuous. If f′f' changes from positive to negative at cc, ff has a relative maximum there; from negative to positive, a relative minimum. If f′f' keeps its sign, there is no relative extremum at cc.

Worked example 11.4: a sign chart with a gap. Continue with f′(x)=x(x−2)(x−1)2f'(x)=\frac{x(x-2)}{(x-1)^2}.

IntervalTest inputSign of f′f'Behavior of ff
(−∞,0)(-\infty,0)−1-1++increasing
(0,1)(0,1)0.50.5−-decreasing
(1,2)(1,2)1.51.5−-decreasing
(2,∞)(2,\infty)33++increasing

f′f' changes from positive to negative at 0, so f(0)=0f(0)=0 is a relative maximum. It changes from negative to positive at 2, so f(2)=4f(2)=4 is a relative minimum. Write "decreasing on (0,1)(0,1) and on (1,2)(1,2)," not "on (0,2)(0,2)": 1 is not in the domain. Notice that the relative maximum value, 0, is smaller than the relative minimum value, 4. "Relative" compares only nearby inputs.

Worked example 11.5: diagnose an incorrect solution. A student is asked for the relative extrema of f(x)=x44−x3f(x)=\frac{x^4}{4}-x^3 and writes: "f′(x)=x3−3x2=0f'(x)=x^3-3x^2=0 at x=0x=0 and x=3x=3, so ff has relative extrema at x=0x=0 and x=3x=3."

The zeros are correct candidates; the conclusion skipped the test. Factor: f′(x)=x2(x−3)f'(x)=x^2(x-3). The factor x2x^2 is positive except at 0, so f′f' has the sign of x−3x-3: negative on both sides of 0 and positive for x>3x>3. Repair: "f′f' is negative on both sides of x=0x=0, so ff has no extremum there. f′f' changes from negative to positive at x=3x=3, so ff has a relative minimum at x=3x=3, where f(3)=−274f(3)=-\frac{27}{4}."

Try it 11.2. For f(x)=x−3x1/3f(x)=x-3x^{1/3}, find every critical number, the intervals where ff increases or decreases, and each relative extremum.

Solution. f′(x)=1−x−2/3=x2/3−1x2/3f'(x)=1-x^{-2/3}=\frac{x^{2/3}-1}{x^{2/3}}. Critical numbers: −1-1 and 11, where f′=0f'=0, and 00, where f′f' is undefined but f(0)=0f(0)=0 is defined. The denominator is positive for x≠0x\neq 0, so f′>0f'>0 on (−∞,−1)(-\infty,-1) and (1,∞)(1,\infty) and f′<0f'<0 on (−1,0)(-1,0) and (0,1)(0,1). Relative maximum f(−1)=2f(-1)=2; relative minimum f(1)=−2f(1)=-2; no extremum at 0, where f′f' stays negative.

Absolute extrema: the Candidates Test (topic 5.5)

For ff continuous on a closed interval [a,b][a,b]:

  1. Confirm continuity on [a,b][a,b], so the Extreme Value Theorem guarantees both extremes exist.
  2. List the candidates: both endpoints and every critical number in (a,b)(a,b).
  3. Evaluate ff, not f′f', at every candidate.
  4. The largest value is the absolute maximum and the smallest is the absolute minimum. Report each value and every input where it occurs, including ties.

Graph of y equals the absolute value of x squared minus 4 for x from negative 3 to 2.5, with five labeled candidate points: the left endpoint (negative 3, 5), a sharp corner at (negative 2, 0), a rounded peak with a horizontal tangent at (0, 4), a sharp corner at (2, 0), and the right endpoint (2.5, 2.25). A small table beside the graph lists the five candidate values 5, 0, 4, 0 and 2.25.

Figure 11.2. Every kind of candidate on [−3,2.5][-3,2.5]: endpoints, corners where f′f' does not exist, and a stationary point. The local maximum at x=0x=0 loses the global comparison, and the minimum value is a tie.

Read the figure the way the test works. The corners at x=±2x=\pm 2 are candidates because the derivative does not exist there, the peak at x=0x=0 because the derivative is 0, and the endpoints because the interval stops there. Only the comparison of function values decides: the maximum, 5, occurs at the endpoint x=−3x=-3, and the minimum, 0, occurs at two inputs.

Worked example 11.6: choose the method. Find the absolute extrema of p(x)=xe−x/2p(x)=xe^{-x/2} (a) on [0,5][0,5] and (b) on [0,∞)[0,\infty).

(a) The interval is closed and pp is continuous, so use the Candidates Test. p′(x)=e−x/2(1−x2)p'(x)=e^{-x/2}\left(1-\frac{x}{2}\right), which is 0 only at x=2x=2 because e−x/2>0e^{-x/2}>0. The values are p(0)=0p(0)=0, p(2)=2e≈0.736p(2)=\frac{2}{e}\approx 0.736 and p(5)=5e−5/2≈0.410p(5)=5e^{-5/2}\approx 0.410. The absolute maximum is 2e\frac{2}{e} at x=2x=2; the absolute minimum is 0 at x=0x=0.

(b) With no right endpoint, the Candidates Test cannot list every candidate. Use the sign of p′p' instead: p′>0p'>0 on (0,2)(0,2) and p′<0p'<0 on (2,∞)(2,\infty), so pp rises to x=2x=2 and falls afterward. The absolute maximum is again 2e\frac{2}{e}. Since p(x)>0p(x)>0 for x>0x>0 and p(0)=0p(0)=0, the absolute minimum is 0 at x=0x=0. A sign argument about a single critical number works on any interval; the Candidates Test needs a closed one.

In calculator-required work, a critical number may come from a numerical solver. Store its full value and still evaluate every endpoint (Chapter 23).

Try it 11.3. Find the absolute maximum and minimum of q(x)=x3−12xq(x)=x^3-12x on [−3,5][-3,5].

Solution. q′(x)=3x2−12=0q'(x)=3x^2-12=0 at x=±2x=\pm 2, both inside. Values: q(−3)=9q(-3)=9, q(−2)=16q(-2)=16, q(2)=−16q(2)=-16, q(5)=65q(5)=65. The absolute maximum is 65 at the endpoint x=5x=5; the absolute minimum is −16-16 at x=2x=2. The relative maximum at x=−2x=-2 is not absolute.

Write the justification

Name the function and the derivative fact, give the reason, then state the conclusion.

IncompleteComplete
"f′(3)=0f'(3)=0, so the maximum is at 3.""f′f' changes from positive to negative at x=3x=3, so ff has a relative maximum at x=3x=3."
"The graph goes up, then down.""f′>0f'>0 on (1,3)(1,3) and f′<0f'<0 on (3,5)(3,5), so ..."
"The MVT gives c=4c=4.""ff is continuous on [1,9][1,9] and differentiable on (1,9)(1,9), so by the MVT some cc in (1,9)(1,9) has f′(c)=14f'(c)=\frac{1}{4}; c=4c=4."
"The largest critical value is the maximum.""ff is continuous on [a,b][a,b]; comparing ff at both endpoints and every critical number, the largest value is ..."

Practice

This chapter's bank items are APCAL-C11-M01 to APCAL-C11-M15, printed after the companion panel as Questions 139–153, and the nine-point written tasks APCAL-C11-F01 and APCAL-C11-F02, printed as Written tasks 14 and 15. Questions 150–153 and Written task 15 require a graphing calculator in radian mode; the rest are without a calculator. Answers, the error behind each wrong choice, rubrics and complete responses are in Answers, explanations and written responses, under Chapter 11: answers and explanations.

For retrieval, wait two days. Then, without notes, write the hypotheses of both theorems and redo Worked example 11.5 from its prompt. About a week later, rework Try it 11.3 on [−3,1][-3,1] instead; the answer changes to a maximum of 16 at x=−2x=-2 and a minimum of −11-11 at the endpoint x=1x=1.

Use this chapter companion

Review the lesson, attempt the original practice, then check the explanation. Your printed study guide remains complete without the website.

Independence

Skill by Skill Prep is independent. SAT® and AP® are trademarks registered by the College Board, which is not affiliated with, and does not endorse, this website or book. PSAT/NMSQT® is a registered trademark of the College Board and the National Merit Scholarship Corporation, which are not affiliated with, and do not endorse, this site. Bluebook™ is a trademark of the College Board. ACT® is a trademark of ACT Education Corp., which is not affiliated with and does not endorse this website or book. Desmos is a trademark of Desmos Studio PBC. Practice results describe these questions, not official scores or admission predictions.

Last updated .