Connect functions and derivative graphs

Translate sign and concavity information between derivative graphs

What to practice

  • Translate sign and concavity information between derivative graphs

Chapter 11 read the sign of f′f'. This chapter adds a second layer: how f′f' itself changes, which f′′f'' measures. Keep the levels straight. The sign of f′f' says whether ff rises or falls; whether f′f' rises or falls says how the graph of ff bends. A graph of one level gives information about the others, but not all of it. A graph of f′f' fixes the shape of ff, not its height.

Predict first. A graph falls from left to right and is concave up. Are its slopes increasing or decreasing? Keep your answer for the next section.

Concavity measures changing slope (topic 5.6)

The graph of ff is concave up on an open interval if f′f' is increasing there, and concave down if f′f' is decreasing. When f′′f'' exists, f′′>0f''>0 on an interval gives concave up and f′′<0f''<0 gives concave down. Concavity is about slopes changing, not about height or direction. A falling graph can be concave up: its slopes are negative but increasing toward 0, which answers the prediction.

A point of inflection is a point where ff is continuous and its concavity changes. Inputs where f′′=0f''=0 or f′′f'' does not exist are only candidates. A candidate becomes an inflection point when the sign of f′′f'' actually changes there.

Common errors. Concave up does not mean increasing, and a zero of f′′f'' is not automatically an inflection point. Nor does an inflection point require f′′=0f''=0. For f(x)=x1/3f(x)=x^{1/3}, f′′(x)=−29x−5/3f''(x)=-\frac{2}{9}x^{-5/3} is undefined at 0, yet it is positive for x<0x<0 and negative for x>0x>0, so the graph changes concavity at the origin.

Concavity and tangent lines. Near a point where the graph is concave up, the graph lies above its tangent line, so a tangent-line estimate there is an underestimate; where it is concave down, the estimate is an overestimate. Chapter 10 used this fact for local linear approximation.

Two side-by-side graphs on the interval from negative 1.5 to 1.5. Left: y equals x cubed, passing through the origin with a horizontal tangent there; a sign strip below the graph shows f double prime negative for x less than 0 and positive for x greater than 0. Right: y equals x to the fourth, with its lowest point at the origin and a horizontal tangent there; its sign strip shows f double prime positive on both sides of 0. Each panel notes that f double prime of 0 equals 0.

Figure 12.1. Both functions have f′′(0)=0f''(0)=0. Only x3x^3 changes concavity at 0, so only it has a point of inflection there.

Worked example 12.1: concavity from a formula. Analyze the concavity of f(x)=xe−xf(x)=xe^{-x}.

f′(x)=e−x(1−x)f'(x)=e^{-x}(1-x) and f′′(x)=e−x(x−2)f''(x)=e^{-x}(x-2). Check the second derivative by differentiating f′f': −e−x(1−x)−e−x=e−x(x−2)-e^{-x}(1-x)-e^{-x}=e^{-x}(x-2). Because e−x>0e^{-x}>0, f′′f'' has the sign of x−2x-2. The graph is concave down on (−∞,2)(-\infty,2) and concave up on (2,∞)(2,\infty), with a point of inflection at (2,2e−2)≈(2,0.271)\left(2,2e^{-2}\right)\approx(2,0.271). Direction is independent: ff decreases on (1,∞)(1,\infty), bending down on (1,2)(1,2) and up on (2,∞)(2,\infty).

Worked example 12.2: diagnose an incorrect solution. For f(x)=x5−5x4f(x)=x^5-5x^4, a student writes: "f′′(x)=20x3−60x2=0f''(x)=20x^3-60x^2=0 at x=0x=0 and x=3x=3, so the graph has points of inflection at both."

The student found candidates and stopped. Factor: f′′(x)=20x2(x−3)f''(x)=20x^2(x-3). The factor 20x220x^2 is positive except at 0, so f′′f'' has the sign of x−3x-3: negative on both sides of 0 and positive for x>3x>3. Repair: "f′′f'' changes sign at x=3x=3 and not at x=0x=0, so the only point of inflection is (3,−162)(3,-162)."

The Second Derivative Test (topic 5.7)

Suppose f′(c)=0f'(c)=0 and f′′(c)f''(c) exists. If f′′(c)<0f''(c)<0, ff has a relative maximum at cc: a horizontal tangent on a graph that bends down. If f′′(c)>0f''(c)>0, ff has a relative minimum at cc. If f′′(c)=0f''(c)=0, the test gives no conclusion. The functions x4x^4, −x4-x^4 and x3x^3 all have f′(0)=0f'(0)=0 and f′′(0)=0f''(0)=0, yet they give a minimum, a maximum and neither. Return to the First Derivative Test.

One more conclusion is often useful. If a continuous function has only one critical number on an interval and that critical number gives a relative extremum, it gives the absolute extremum on that interval. Worked example 11.6(b) used this idea.

Worked example 12.3: choose the test. Classify the critical numbers of (a) h(x)=x4−8x2h(x)=x^4-8x^2 and (b) q(x)=3x5−5x3q(x)=3x^5-5x^3.

(a) h′(x)=4x(x−2)(x+2)h'(x)=4x(x-2)(x+2), so the critical numbers are −2-2, 0 and 2. Since h′′(x)=12x2−16h''(x)=12x^2-16 is easy to evaluate, use the Second Derivative Test: h′′(0)=−16<0h''(0)=-16<0 gives a relative maximum, and h′′(±2)=32>0h''(\pm 2)=32>0 gives relative minima.

(b) q′(x)=15x2(x2−1)q'(x)=15x^2(x^2-1), with critical numbers −1-1, 0 and 1. With q′′(x)=60x3−30xq''(x)=60x^3-30x, q′′(−1)=−30q''(-1)=-30 gives a relative maximum and q′′(1)=30q''(1)=30 a relative minimum. But q′′(0)=0q''(0)=0, so switch tests. q′q' is negative on (−1,0)(-1,0) and on (0,1)(0,1), so qq has no extremum at 0. Use the Second Derivative Test when f′′f'' is easy and nonzero; use the First Derivative Test when f′′(c)=0f''(c)=0 or when intervals are needed anyway.

Try it 12.1. For g(x)=x4−4x3+4x2g(x)=x^4-4x^3+4x^2, classify each critical number with the Second Derivative Test, then find the xx-coordinates of the points of inflection.

Solution. g′(x)=4x(x−1)(x−2)g'(x)=4x(x-1)(x-2) and g′′(x)=12x2−24x+8g''(x)=12x^2-24x+8. g′′(0)=8g''(0)=8 and g′′(2)=8g''(2)=8 give relative minima; g′′(1)=−4g''(1)=-4 gives a relative maximum. g′′=0g''=0 at x=1±33x=1\pm\frac{\sqrt{3}}{3}, about 0.423 and 1.577. These are simple zeros of a quadratic, so g′′g'' changes sign at each and both are inflection points.

Where is a function changing most rapidly?

The rate of change of ff is f′f', so "increasing most rapidly" asks for the absolute maximum of f′f', not of ff. Apply Chapter 11's Candidates Test one level up: on a closed interval, compare f′f' at both endpoints and at every input where f′′f'' is 0 or undefined.

Worked example 12.4: the rate's candidates. For f(t)=t3−9t2+24tf(t)=t^3-9t^2+24t on [0,5][0,5], f′(t)=3t2−18t+24f'(t)=3t^2-18t+24 and f′′(t)=6t−18f''(t)=6t-18, which is 0 at t=3t=3. Compare f′(0)=24f'(0)=24, f′(3)=−3f'(3)=-3 and f′(5)=9f'(5)=9. The function increases most rapidly at the endpoint t=0t=0 and decreases most rapidly at t=3t=3, its inflection point. An inflection point marks a rate that is extreme only among nearby inputs; here the endpoint wins the maximum.

With a calculator. When f′′=0f''=0 cannot be solved by hand, differentiate as far as you reliably can, graph f′′f'' (or the numerical derivative of f′f') in radian mode on the stated interval, locate each zero with the solver, and confirm the sign change by evaluating f′′f'' on both sides. A graph of ff alone rarely shows where its bending changes. Store full values before reusing them (Chapter 23).

Read one graph to learn about another (topics 5.8 and 5.9)

Evidence about f′f'Conclusion about ff
f′>0f'>0 (or f′<0f'<0) on an intervalff is increasing (or decreasing) there
f′f' changes from ++ to −- (or −- to ++)relative maximum (or minimum) of ff
f′f' is increasing (or decreasing)graph of ff is concave up (or down)
relative extremum of f′f'point of inflection of ff

The same table works one level up, with f′′f'' describing f′f'. What a graph of f′f' cannot give is the height of ff. Functions that differ by a constant share a derivative, so one known value, an anchor such as f(0)=3f(0)=3, is needed to place ff.

Two stacked graphs with the same horizontal axis from x equals negative 3 to 2.5. Top: the graph of g prime of x equals (x minus 1) squared times (x plus 2); it is negative left of x equals negative 2, crosses the axis upward at x equals negative 2, rises to a high point at (negative 1, 4), falls to touch the axis at (1, 0), and rises again. A sign row beneath reads minus, plus, plus with breaks at negative 2 and 1. Bottom: two vertically shifted copies of g, one solid and one dashed 3 units higher; both have a lowest point at x equals negative 2, a level point with a horizontal tangent at x equals 1, and inflection points marked at x equals negative 1 and x equals 1.

Figure 12.2. A derivative graph and two functions that share it. Every location matches; only the heights differ.

Worked example 12.5: read a derivative graph. Using only the top panel of Figure 12.2, describe gg.

  • Direction. g′<0g'<0 on (−3,−2)(-3,-2) and g′>0g'>0 on (−2,1)(-2,1) and (1,2.5)(1,2.5). So gg has a relative minimum at x=−2x=-2. At x=1x=1, g′g' touches 0 without changing sign: a horizontal tangent, but no extremum.
  • Concavity. g′g' increases on (−3,−1)(-3,-1), decreases on (−1,1)(-1,1) and increases on (1,2.5)(1,2.5). So gg is concave down only on (−1,1)(-1,1), with points of inflection at x=−1x=-1 and x=1x=1.
  • Independent check. Expanding, g′(x)=x3−3x+2g'(x)=x^3-3x+2, so g′′(x)=3(x−1)(x+1)g''(x)=3(x-1)(x+1), whose signs agree.
  • Height. Both lower curves fit every statement; an anchor such as g(0)=3g(0)=3 selects the dashed one.

Worked example 12.6: sketch from a description. A function ff is continuous on [0,6][0,6] with f(0)=1f(0)=1. f′>0f'>0 on (0,2)(0,2) and f′<0f'<0 on (2,6)(2,6); f′′<0f''<0 on (0,4)(0,4) and f′′>0f''>0 on (4,6)(4,6). Build a feature list before drawing. From (0,1)(0,1) the graph rises while bending down. It peaks at x=2x=2, which is the absolute maximum because ff increases before 2 and decreases after it. It falls while bending down to an inflection point at x=4x=4, then keeps falling while bending up, so its descent flattens. Any curve with these features is acceptable. The data fix no height beyond f(0)=1f(0)=1, so do not invent one.

Three separate graphs labeled I, II and III, each for x from negative 3 to 5. Graph I is a straight line rising from (negative 3, negative 8) to (5, 8) that crosses the x-axis at x equals 1. Graph II is an S-shaped cubic curve that rises to a high point at (negative 1, 5 thirds), falls to a low point at (3, negative 9), and rises to (5, 5 thirds). Graph III is a parabola opening upward with its lowest point at (1, negative 4), crossing the x-axis at x equals negative 1 and x equals 3.

Figure 12.3. One function, its derivative and its second derivative, in an unknown order.

Worked example 12.7: match three graphs. Figure 12.3 shows ff, f′f' and f′′f'' in some order. Look for a graph whose zeros line up with another graph's turning points. Graph III crosses zero at −1-1 and 3, exactly where graph II turns, and III is positive where II rises. So III is the derivative of II. Graph I crosses zero at 1, where III has its lowest point, and I is negative where III falls. So I is the derivative of III. Therefore II is ff, III is f′f' and I is f′′f''. Check the other orders: graph I is a line, so its derivative would be a constant, which no graph shows; and graph II is 0 at the origin rather than at x=1x=1, where III turns, so II is not the derivative of III.

Try it 12.2. A twice-differentiable ff has f′(−1)=0f'(-1)=0 and f′(3)=0f'(3)=0, with f′′(x)<0f''(x)<0 for x<1x<1 and f′′(x)>0f''(x)>0 for x>1x>1. Classify x=−1x=-1 and x=3x=3, locate the point of inflection, and explain why f′f' is least at x=1x=1.

Solution. f′′(−1)<0f''(-1)<0, so x=−1x=-1 gives a relative maximum; f′′(3)>0f''(3)>0, so x=3x=3 gives a relative minimum. f′′f'' changes sign at x=1x=1, so the point of inflection is at x=1x=1. Since f′′<0f''<0 before 1 and f′′>0f''>0 after it, f′f' decreases and then increases, so f′(1)f'(1) is its least value.

Write justifications from derivative graphs

Name the level you are reading. "ff is concave down on (−1,1)(-1,1) because f′f' is decreasing there" is complete. "Because ff is decreasing" uses the wrong level, and "because f′′f'' is decreasing" describes how concavity changes, not its sign. For an inflection point, write "f′′f'' changes sign at x=3x=3" or "f′f' changes from decreasing to increasing at x=3x=3," never only "f′′(3)=0f''(3)=0." When the supplied graph is of f′f', say so: "the graph of f′f' is above the axis on (−2,1)(-2,1)."

For the Second Derivative Test, state both facts: "f′(2)=0f'(2)=0 and f′′(2)<0f''(2)<0, so ff has a relative maximum at x=2x=2." A negative f′′(2)f''(2) alone says only that the graph bends down near 2; without f′(2)=0f'(2)=0 the test has not been applied. When a question asks how f′f' behaves, treat f′′f'' as its derivative and reuse the same sentences one level up.

Practice

This chapter's bank items are APCAL-C12-M01 to APCAL-C12-M15, printed after the companion panel as Questions 154–168, and the nine-point written tasks APCAL-C12-F01 and APCAL-C12-F02, printed as Written tasks 16 and 17. Questions 164–168 and Written task 17 require a graphing calculator in radian mode; the rest are without a calculator. Answers, the error behind each wrong choice, rubrics and complete responses are under Chapter 12: answers and explanations in Answers, explanations and written responses.

For retrieval, wait two days, then redraw Figure 12.2's top panel from memory and rewrite Worked example 12.5's four conclusions. About a week later, mix this chapter with Chapter 11: for f′(x)=x(x−4)2f'(x)=x(x-4)^2, find the relative extrema and inflection points without labels telling you which test to use. Check: a relative minimum at x=0x=0, no extremum at x=4x=4, and inflection points at x=43x=\frac{4}{3} and x=4x=4.

Use this chapter companion

Review the lesson, attempt the original practice, then check the explanation. Your printed study guide remains complete without the website.

Independence

Skill by Skill Prep is independent. SAT® and AP® are trademarks registered by the College Board, which is not affiliated with, and does not endorse, this website or book. PSAT/NMSQT® is a registered trademark of the College Board and the National Merit Scholarship Corporation, which are not affiliated with, and do not endorse, this site. Bluebook™ is a trademark of the College Board. ACT® is a trademark of ACT Education Corp., which is not affiliated with and does not endorse this website or book. Desmos is a trademark of Desmos Studio PBC. Practice results describe these questions, not official scores or admission predictions.

Last updated .