Write complete mathematical justifications

Compare a complete argument with a repairable partial response

What to practice

  • Compare a complete argument with a repairable partial response

A justification turns a correct answer into an argument that a reader can check. Free-response scoring often separates the reasoning from the number: published scoring notes award points for a setup, a stated condition or an interpretation, not only for a final value (see the task-specific notes in the 2026 AP Calculus AB scoring guidelines). A correct number with a missing reason can therefore lose points. This chapter adds no new questions. It teaches you to repair responses you have already written, across all eight units.

The four parts of a complete argument

  1. Claim. State what you conclude, about which function, at which input or on which interval.
  2. Conditions. If a theorem or test supplies the conclusion, show that its hypotheses hold for this function.
  3. Evidence. Give the specific values, signs or computations that the reason uses.
  4. Conclusion in context. Join evidence to claim with "because … therefore", using units and the problem's own words.

The parts need not appear in this order, and a short response can combine them in one sentence. What matters is that none is missing.

A diagram of four stacked boxes joined by downward arrows, labeled 1 Claim, 2 Conditions, 3 Evidence and 4 Conclusion in context, each with a one-line description matching the list above. A dashed box at the top quotes a partial response: g(1) = −2 and g(4) = 3, so g(c) = 0 for some c. Beside each box the response is checked: claim partial, since the interval for c is not stated; conditions missing, since continuity of g on the interval from 1 to 4 is not shown and a jump could skip 0; evidence present, g(1) < 0 < g(4); conclusion incomplete, since no theorem is named and c is not placed between 1 and 4.

Figure 22.1. A complete argument links claim, conditions, evidence and a conclusion in context. The partial response above the boxes has the evidence but skips a condition.

Check the hypotheses before naming a theorem

A theorem guarantees its conclusion only when its hypotheses hold. If one fails, the theorem is silent: the conclusion might still be true, but you need another reason. Hypotheses are sufficient conditions, not necessary ones.

Theorem or ruleHypotheses to stateGuaranteed conclusion
Intermediate Value Theoremff continuous on [a,b][a,b]; kk strictly between f(a)f(a) and f(b)f(b)some cc in (a,b)(a,b) with f(c)=kf(c)=k
Mean Value Theoremff continuous on [a,b][a,b] and differentiable on (a,b)(a,b)some cc in (a,b)(a,b) with f′(c)=f(b)−f(a)b−af'(c)=\frac{f(b)-f(a)}{b-a}
Extreme Value Theoremff continuous on the closed interval [a,b][a,b]ff attains an absolute maximum value and an absolute minimum value on [a,b][a,b], each at least once
Fundamental Theorem, derivative formff continuous on an interval containing aa and xxddx∫axf(t) dt=f(x)\frac{d}{dx}\int_{a}^{x}f(t)\,dt=f(x)
L'Hospital's rulethe limit has the form 00\frac{0}{0} or ∞∞\frac{\infty}{\infty}; ff and gg differentiable near aa with g′(x)≠0g'(x)\neq 0 there; lim⁡f′g′\lim\frac{f'}{g'} existslim⁡x→af(x)g(x)=lim⁡x→af′(x)g′(x)\lim_{x\to a}\frac{f(x)}{g(x)}=\lim_{x\to a}\frac{f'(x)}{g'(x)}

The Extreme Value Theorem row follows the current wording, which guarantees at least one maximum value and at least one minimum value (Fall 2026 course framework corrections); each extreme value is attained, possibly at more than one input. Differentiability implies continuity, but continuity does not imply differentiability. When a problem says ff is differentiable, say that ff is therefore continuous.

Three graphs. Panel (a): a function on the interval from 0 to 2 made of two line segments; it rises from a filled dot at (0, −1) to an open circle at (1, −0.5), then jumps up to a filled dot at (1, 0.5) and rises to a filled dot at (2, 1). A dashed horizontal line marks the target value 0, which the graph never meets. Panel (b): the graph of the absolute value of x minus 1 on the interval from 0 to 3, a V shape with a corner at (1, 0), and a dashed secant from (0, 1) to (3, 2) with slope 1/3; the graph's slopes are only −1 and 1. Panel (c): the line y = x from a filled dot at (0, 0) to an open circle at (1, 1), with a separate filled dot at (1, 0); a dashed line y = 1 is approached but never reached.

Figure 22.2. Remove one hypothesis and the conclusion can fail. (a) A jump skips the value 0. (b) At a corner, no tangent slope equals the secant slope 13\frac{1}{3}. (c) A discontinuity at an endpoint leaves no largest value.

Repair six partial responses

Each repair keeps the correct work and adds only what is missing.

Repair 1: a sign change without continuity (Unit 1)

Partial: "g(1)=−2g(1)=-2 and g(4)=3g(4)=3, so g(c)=0g(c)=0 for some cc." Suppose gg is differentiable.

Missing: continuity, which a jump would break, as in Figure 22.2(a).

Repaired: "Because gg is differentiable, it is continuous on [1,4][1,4]. Since g(1)=−2<0<3=g(4)g(1)=-2<0<3=g(4), the Intermediate Value Theorem gives a cc in (1,4)(1,4) with g(c)=0g(c)=0."

Repair 2: a local fact used for a global claim (Unit 5)

Partial: "f′(2)=0f'(2)=0, so ff has its absolute maximum on [0,5][0,5] at x=2x=2."

Missing: a derivative zero only makes 2 a candidate. An absolute extremum needs every candidate and both endpoints.

Repaired, given that ff is differentiable, 2 is its only critical number, and f(0)=1f(0)=1, f(2)=7f(2)=7, f(5)=4f(5)=4: "ff is continuous on [0,5][0,5], so its absolute maximum occurs at a critical number or an endpoint. Of f(0)=1f(0)=1, f(2)=7f(2)=7 and f(5)=4f(5)=4, the largest is 7, so the absolute maximum value is 7, at x=2x=2."

Repair 3: speed judged from one sign (Unit 4)

Partial: "v(3)=−4v(3)=-4, so the particle is slowing down at t=3t=3."

Missing: speed depends on velocity and acceleration together. Suppose a(3)=−2a(3)=-2.

Repaired: "At t=3t=3, v(3)=−4<0v(3)=-4<0 and a(3)=−2<0a(3)=-2<0. Velocity and acceleration have the same sign, so the speed is increasing: the particle is speeding up."

Repair 4: a change reported as an amount (Units 6 and 8)

Water enters a tank at r(t)r(t) liters per hour, and the tank holds 40 liters at t=0t=0.

Partial: "Amount =∫06r(t) dt=18=\int_{0}^{6}r(t)\,dt=18."

Missing: the integral of a rate is the change in the amount, not the amount; units and the starting value are absent.

Repaired: "∫06r(t) dt=18\int_{0}^{6}r(t)\,dt=18 liters is the change in the amount of water from t=0t=0 to t=6t=6 hours. The tank holds 40+18=5840+18=58 liters at t=6t=6."

Repair 5: dividing away the solution (Unit 7)

Solve dydx=x(y−2)\frac{dy}{dx}=x(y-2) with y(0)=2y(0)=2.

Partial: "dyy−2=x dx\frac{dy}{y-2}=x\,dx, so ln⁡∣y−2∣=x22+C\ln|y-2|=\frac{x^2}{2}+C. At x=0x=0 this needs ln⁡0\ln 0, so there is no solution."

Missing: dividing by y−2y-2 assumed y≠2y\neq 2. Check that case before dividing.

Repaired: "If y=2y=2 for all xx, then dydx=0\frac{dy}{dx}=0 and x(2−2)=0x(2-2)=0, so the constant function y=2y=2 satisfies the equation, and y(0)=2y(0)=2. The particular solution is y=2y=2 for all real xx." This equation has a whole family of solutions; the initial condition selects one.

Repair 6: a calculator number without its equation (Unit 8)

Partial: "x=1.895x=1.895."

Missing: what equation was solved, on what interval, and what the root means.

Repaired: "The region's curves y=sin⁡xy=\sin x and y=x2y=\frac{x}{2} meet where sin⁡x=x2\sin x=\frac{x}{2}. On (0,π)(0,\pi), a calculator gives x=1.895494x=1.895494, which I store at full precision. So the region's right boundary is x≈1.895x\approx 1.895."

Units and contextual conclusions

  • A derivative's units are output units per input unit. An integral of a rate has the units of the accumulated amount. Areas are square units; volumes are cubic.
  • An interpretation names the value, the units, the input and the direction: "H′(5)=−0.4H'(5)=-0.4 means that at t=5t=5 minutes the depth is decreasing at 0.4 centimeter per minute."
  • Write ≈\approx for a rounded value. Round only the reported answer, to three decimal places unless told otherwise.

Linked parts and carried values

When a later part uses an earlier answer, use your earlier value even if you doubt it, and say so: "Using V=21.5V=21.5 from part (a), …". A rubric may award a later point for a correct method applied to your earlier value. It cannot do that when the later part is blank or the dependence is hidden. Never round an earlier answer before reusing it.

Try it

Try it 22.1. The depth of water in a channel is h(t)h(t) meters, tt hours after noon, and hh is differentiable. A student writes: "Since h(0)=5h(0)=5 and h(4)=1h(4)=1, there is a time cc with h′(c)=−1h'(c)=-1." Repair the response.

Check your repair. "Because hh is differentiable, it is continuous on [0,4][0,4] and differentiable on (0,4)(0,4). By the Mean Value Theorem there is a cc in (0,4)(0,4) with h′(c)=1−54−0=−1h'(c)=\frac{1-5}{4-0}=-1. So at some time between noon and 4 p.m., the depth was falling at 1 meter per hour."

Try it 22.2. Given f′′(x)=6x−18f''(x)=6x-18, a student writes: "The graph of ff is concave down on (1,3)(1,3) because ff is decreasing there." Repair it.

Check your repair. Concavity depends on f′′f'', not on the sign of f′f'. "For 1<x<31<x<3, f′′(x)=6x−18<0f''(x)=6x-18<0, so f′f' is decreasing and the graph of ff is concave down on (1,3)(1,3)."

Try it 22.3. A particle's velocity is v(t)v(t) meters per second, and ∫010v(t) dt=−12\int_{0}^{10}v(t)\,dt=-12. A student writes: "The particle traveled 12 meters." Repair it.

Check your repair. The integral is displacement, not distance. "At t=10t=10 seconds the particle is 12 meters in the negative direction from its position at t=0t=0." The distance traveled is ∫010∣v(t)∣ dt\int_{0}^{10}|v(t)|\,dt, at least 12 meters; it equals 12 only if vv never changes sign.

Practice

Chapter 22 adds no numbered questions. Choose two written tasks that you have already attempted and scored below full credit, ideally from different units; Written tasks 29 and 30 from Chapter 21 qualify if you scored below full credit on them. For each one:

  1. Underline every claim in your original response.
  2. Beside each claim, write its conditions, evidence and conclusion in context.
  3. Rewrite the response on fresh paper, keeping the work that was correct.
  4. Rescore it with the printed rubric, and log the item as a dated revisit; it counts once, not as a new question.

Reread Figure 22.1 and the hypothesis table before each mock, and repeat this repair on one task in each review week.

Use this chapter companion

Review the lesson, attempt the original practice, then check the explanation. Your printed study guide remains complete without the website.

Independence

Skill by Skill Prep is independent. SAT® and AP® are trademarks registered by the College Board, which is not affiliated with, and does not endorse, this website or book. PSAT/NMSQT® is a registered trademark of the College Board and the National Merit Scholarship Corporation, which are not affiliated with, and do not endorse, this site. Bluebook™ is a trademark of the College Board. ACT® is a trademark of ACT Education Corp., which is not affiliated with and does not endorse this website or book. Desmos is a trademark of Desmos Studio PBC. Practice results describe these questions, not official scores or admission predictions.

Last updated .